3 ms·
I happen to think that inflation and sovereign debt transfer wealth from the poor and middle class to the rich. https://docs.google.com/document/d/137cC3inVNcf
by dnautics 13y ago
I happen to think that inflation and sovereign debt transfer wealth from the poor and middle class to the rich.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/137cC3inVNcfof44Pq1nMiyz1iRPekBsGhSnhAW_GSLs/edit https://docs.google.com/document/d/137cC3inVNcfof44Pq1nMiyz1...
- EGreg 13y agoThey do, but sovereign debt in the USA is mitigated by automatic stabilizers in progressive taxes. On the other hand, the structural problems come from the increased ability for multinational corporations (like Amazon) with small margins to disrupt the comparative advantage of LOCAL businesses and thus lower demand for a lot of local human labor. All the working conditions we've been legilating for in the past 100-200 years make our population more expensive to hire, and when you are now able to hire people in areas with a lower cost of living, or automate the jobs, the problems are systemic. If you reqd Stiglitz, he points out how before the great depression 20% of Americans worked in farm related jobs. After -- 2%. Notice the similarity with manyfacturing? This time it's taken longer but it's steadily eroding demand for local labor. Programmers arent hit by this economic phenomenon yet, because we program the machines that "disrupt" industries.
- dnautics 13y agoare you making the claim that progressive taxation schemes automatically adjust to mathematically compensate? Because, inflation is a compounding effect, and having first action on created money is so powerful that I doubt that taxing the banking classes at anything but 100% or greater would do much for that. Plus bailouts, contracting work, etc. etc. etc.
- EGreg 13y agoI read your essay, and I am not discounting the deleterious effects of inflation on the domestic economy. In fact the growth in the M0 money supply should have us expecting a 3x inflation in the near future: http://www.tradingeconomics.com/united-states/money-supply-m0 http://www.tradingeconomics.com/united-states/money-supply-m... So yes, this is very worrying. As Milton Friedman said, "inflation is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon" and argued that it always follows an increase in the mouney supply. What I am saying is that there are ways to mitigate the transfer of wealth to the rich, which are in place. If you look at inflation as a flat tax on everyone, it can be offset by sufficiently progressive taxation and welfare assistance to the poor (I am a fan of Friedman's negative tax scheme or Basic Income schemes). Overall you are right, income inequality grows during inflations. But at least we can mitigate this with policy. On the other hand, I am saying that the structural changes are systemic and this is far worse for the population as we have very limited means to "bring manufacturing jobs back" as both presidential candidates promised in this last election. They ain't coming back - not to humans, anyway. The real big shift we are facing is how quickly we can grow our safety nets and redistribution schemes like Basic Income or Negative Tax so that our unemployed class can continue being consumers at some rate which we as a society think they "should afford to be" just by virtue of being human.
- dnautics 13y agobut inflation isn't a flat tax on everyone, it's regressive. In the case of the two families in the admittedly extreme inflation example, the poor family takes a 50% tax and the rich family takes a <2% tax. In your graph, I see a 25% inflation, not a 3x inflation. If prices increase too quickly, there will be a dragging effect from the multiplier effect as stressed consumers default on loans, so if M0 doesn't increase as much, that 25% inflation may be dragged out over a longer period of time... Not to understate my worry about it, however. But you're right, the technological displacement is a structural problem in our economy, if the populace has a sense of entitlement towards jobs, or "their job" in particular, or even if not - in the case that there are not enough social resources to effect retraining in the labor force, or those social resources are misdirected, for example towards useless college degrees. In the non-inflationary fantasy universe where I wish I lived, technological displacement wouldn't be such a problem, since it would effect deflation. Yes, people would lose jobs, but they could afford to lose jobs or often, just afford not to work for protracted periods of time if necessary or desired.
- EGreg 13y agoFiat currencies are inherently inflationary. That's because people are forced to accept that currency, and on the basis of the M0 money there is a lot of other money, such as the credit money that far exceeds the amount of M0 money. We regulate how much banks must keep on reserve but ultimately the money supply is inflated not just by governments but by the banks. If every bank issued its own currency, then theoretically its credit would be affected by overextending how much money it lent out. And indeed in the free banking era, many banks failed. (I should point out, though, that even in the so-called free-banking era, the fractional reserve requirements were regulated by the states.) By having a lender of last resort (the Fed), we essentially have replaced a large amount of interbank credit with regulation and a moral hazard. Before computers, it was hard to keep track of so many currencies, but now we might want to revisit that idea. Anyway, all fiat currencies are inflationary. This in itself isn't bad as log as the inflation matches our GDP or at least matches the inflation of every other currency. The Chinese for example peg their currency to the US dollar so they can continue selling us more stuff. I don't know how long this policy will continue. What I am worried about is the trade deficit and the effect of automation and outsourcing on the working class and the general economy. I for example employ developers overseas. Amazon has disrupted bookstores. iTunes has disrupted record stores. The Mac and iPhone, once proudly built in the USA, are now assembled overseas from materials obtained overseas. This is a good thing for the consumer and for flexibility -- supply chains are now all over the world. It is BAD for the environment -- tons of stuff shipped all over the world and wasting fuel merely because capitalism moves things and people around geographically ... producers wanting to produce as much as they can to turn a bigger profit ... this is unsustainable. And it's BAD for the working class, who are in a race to the bottom with people whose cost of living is much smaller, and who -- thanks to recent technological advances -- can take the jobs of local businesses who until now have enjoyed a comparative advantage. When you can't issue your own fiat currency, you fare worse. Witness the PIGS countries in Europe after they lost the ability to issue their own currency. They're all in the south and their economies are slower-paced. I would wager that their trade deficits were quickly affected as the local businesses lost their comparative advantage, but their own governments couldn't help them by printing money, only by borrowing. So they became at the mercy of German and English banks. A similar situation faces many cities in the USA.
- tsotha 13y agoWe may be gone before it happens, but it's only a matter of time before most brain work is automated as well.