3 ms·
Somehow the process that is selecting computer programmers out of the general population disproportionately selects men. Unless you believe that the dearth of
by idlewords 17y ago
Somehow the process that is selecting computer programmers out of the general population disproportionately selects men. Unless you believe that the dearth of women in the field is driven by biology (and there the evidence is against you), it's pretty clear that women are being deterred from hacking by social factors. Saying "we need more women in CS" is equivalent to saying, let's stop driving half the talent out of our field.
- Radix 17y agoPerhaps I should have said "Lack of women in the field..." But I was trying to be general. I implicitly agree that the problem is social, and was trying to say "crap, with a dearth of women we're missing out on many (?) of the most talented programmers." But that last sentence was a bit off. Now, I believe words matter and can warp intentions over time and there is a danger of getting into a quota-for-quota's-sake mindset (as patio put it). I think that will alienate women as being somehow different from the majority of us, when they have more in common with us than with the rest of the population. So, we kinda agree, I was trying to say what you said, but I think "we need more women in CS" is subtly and notably different. ...partially due to guys asking if they're hot or not... (bottom of thread)
- idlewords 17y agoI think the kind of comments that settle at the bottom of these threads are a good demonstration of why so many women get turned off of computerland.
- axod 17y agoYou should add some evidence to your comments... I've seen no evidence women are driven away en masse from programming by anything other than their own wants and desires. I hang out on IRC quite a lot, and if someone brings up the fact that they're a woman, most people are just 'meh'... it's irrelevant to how they're treated and the value they add to discussion etc. That's one of the great things about this industry - it really does not matter. Girls and boys are very very different biologically, with extremely different strengths and weaknesses. Extremely different brains. Lets stop pretending they're the same.
- dtf 17y agoI think you mean, people are very different biologically, with extremely different strengths and weaknesses and extremely different brains. You cannot reliably make any predictions about a particular person's behaviours, aptitudes or motivations if given only the fact that she's a woman.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- axod 17y agoNo, I don't.
- idlewords 17y agoThe evidence, as I said, is actually against you. http://news.softpedia.com/news/The-Gender-Difference-in-Learning-Math-113149.shtml http://news.softpedia.com/news/The-Gender-Difference-in-Lear...
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- cousin_it 17y agoWhat the paper you linked to actually proves: girls' math scores are just as variable as boys' in some countries and some ethnic groups in the United States such as Asian Americans I could even grant you that this result transfers to all ethnicities, but still legitimately ask: so what? If yesterday's evidence of differing math scores didn't imply differing ability to you, then equal math scores today shouldn't imply equal ability either. Make up your mind, will ya. Till then I'll consider you to be cherrypicking evidence to support a feel-good conclusion.
- axod 17y agoI'm guessing you don't have kids yourself. Once you have a girl and a boy the differences are startling and obvious.