3 ms·
It's clear that the goals are extremely laudable -- to help a disadvantaged group gain experience. But this indeed asks the question, which as far as I can tel
by crazygringo 13y ago
It's clear that the goals are extremely laudable -- to help a disadvantaged group gain experience.
But this indeed asks the question, which as far as I can tell is completely unaddressed on their website: why create a group that excludes others by sex and race? How do they explain to a black 14-year-old that their group isn't going to help him? Or a Hispanic 14-year-old girl? Or any 14-year-old whose parents are below the poverty line, who also wants to learn to code?
Why can't we just help disadvantaged youths in general?
I mean, limiting to a certain location (Miami) is fine. Limiting the number of students who can participate is fine. But I really have a hard time wrapping my head around the idea of telling a black boy that they won't help him, because of the gender he was born as.
- pekk 13y agoIf you want to start a group for black boys, then do it.
- shanelja 13y agoDid you even read the comment? It's not about helping black people or women or Chinese people or men, it's about helping everyone.
- pekk 13y agoSeems to me that it's about complaining when someone else starts groups to help people. Helping people is never wrong.
- Karunamon 13y agoSomething something good intentions. "Helping" doesn't automatically mean you're doing it right or are free from criticism or comment.
- pekk 13y agoIf Black Girls Code is not actually helping the black girls, then it's not helping. "You didn't help everybody" is not a valid criticism of an initiative to help some people. If you have some other people you want helped, then help them yourself rather than shooting down other people's altruism.
- Karunamon 13y agoSaying: "Hey, wait a minute, wouldn't this time and energy be better spent helping all disadvantaged people instead of one small group to the exclusion of others?" ..is a criticism, not a "shooting down". Being altruistic does not grant you a blanket exception from criticism.
- jimzvz 13y ago>Helping people is never wrong. How could you type that with a straight face?
- pekk 13y agoYou're right. Actually it is sinful to help any finite number of people, if you are not helping all of humanity. The best thing to do is to never try to do anything helpful, because then you might be construed as discriminatory by people with a political agenda.
- bilbo0s 13y agoWell... for you it is... but not for the people behind this group. I mean they are free to do what THEY feel is important to them. I, personally, believe they have the wrong approach... but it's how they want to spend their time and money. If you are looking to donate... obviously there are far better organizations to support that would accomplish just what you are alluding to... Helping the disadvantaged. Just not this one.
- seanv 13y agovery good point - I imagine though that it's MAINLY to get attention from groups that would donate to such a cause... The more niche the demographic the easier it is to raise money from institutes who aim to help those demos. So short answer, money probably... We can look at a silver lining and hope they expand into other demos, we will see i guess.
- jimzvz 13y agoand the problem with this is that the groups have a conflict of interest, if they do solve the problem that they are addressing then no one will continue to fund them. So the only way that they can stay in business is to make sure that the problem isn't solved, gets worse or is seen to get worse. Erin Pizzey discusses how this has happened to feminist organisations in this video[1]. [1] - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w5AOj6EhRuY http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w5AOj6EhRuY
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- jlgreco 13y agoWell I mean, I don't think many people are bothered by Girl Scouts focusing on girls. Perhaps that is because Boy Scouts also exists, but back in this domain there is always the developing Hacker Scouts, which is inclusive.
- shantanubala 13y agoThe problem is that it's a lot harder to execute -- if you have a "Kids Code" event, you are guaranteed to get a disproportionately larger number of white males. This isn't just about helping a disadvantaged group, but also signalling to them at a young age that "people like you are also programmers!" Growing up as a minority is something that is difficult to grasp unless you are part of that group -- something as simple as having fewer role models who look like you can impact your choices and decisions to pursue specific careers. And no, they are not refusing to help males. I'm almost 100% sure that if a male asked if he could have some help learning to code, someone would either help him out or point him in a direction where he could get help. The group is just designed in a way to signal to young girls that they should join and learn how to program when pop culture ordinarily defaults to making scientists males (e.g. Big Bang Theory). EDIT: Here's another question: is it wrong for a church to provide support groups for its members? Is that discriminating against other religions? Or is it just an effort to improve a specific community?
- chc 13y ago> But this indeed asks the question, which as far as I can tell is completely unaddressed on their website: why create a group that excludes others by sex and race? How do they explain to a black 14-year-old that their group isn't going to help him? Or a Hispanic 14-year-old girl? Or any 14-year-old whose parents are below the poverty line, who also wants to learn to code? You read Hacker News. Surely you understand the importance of focus to any endeavor. The same principle applies here as to a startup — it's easier to sell "Twitter for internal business teams" than "this is an app that, like, helps people communicate and stuff in various ways."
- duaneb 13y agoI think a better way to view these types of groups (and why they are so specialized) may be to view them as support groups almost entirely focused on pragmatic results and functional improvements (as opposed to psychological ones). Restricting them by defining characteristics encourages people defined by those same characteristics to participate when otherwise they might not.
- thinkpad20 13y agoThere's nothing wrong with helping one particular group, when that group needs it. Every charitable organization has to choose some particular problem to address, and by extension, choose NOT to address other problems. If they have too wide of a focus, then they risk losing effectiveness (particularly if their resources are small). By focusing on one distinct group, which is clearly underrepresented in the CS world, this group has a higher chance of success than one with a more vague "let's help everyone" mentality.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]