5 ms·
Just the opposite. We already know that she chose physics even though the prior of being a woman made that choice less likely. We can infer that she was probabl
by jjoonathan 13y ago
Just the opposite. We already know that she chose physics even though the prior of being a woman made that choice less likely. We can infer that she was probably more dedicated to the subject itself than her average peer. The fact that she eventually made it in academia supports this hypothesis.
Another possibility is that she had a partner willing to support her if things went south. Obviously this situation isn't unique to women, but I do think it's slightly more probable for a woman to have such a partner. If this is the case, PaulHoule's point becomes that the decision to enter grad school only made sense for her because of the artificially reduced consequences of p(failure).
Even if affirmative action did play a role (a recent paper found very damning, well-controlled evidence of systematic bias against women in the evaluation process, so I wouldn't assume this with any degree of certainty), PaulHoule could have simply been observing that she saw a better p(success) and was therefore the only one willing to take the leap.
Or maybe PaulHoule is a misogynist. But I'd be willing to bet against you if you still thought that.
- louwrentius 13y agoI understand and you may be right. However, I almost got the impression that 79 students weren't as 'stupid' to enrol in Academia because of the prospects, only the 'women' was. But I'm probably reading tea leaves. Without context, the remark ' a women' is meaningless and almost suspicious. And I think that's my point.