6 ms·
Not only are quitters a large, important subgenre, but so are people warning others not to go—like I do: http://jseliger.wordpress.com/2012/05/22/what-you-shoul
by jseliger 13y ago
Not only are quitters a large, important subgenre, but so are people warning others not to go—like I do: http://jseliger.wordpress.com/2012/05/22/what-you-should-know-before-you-start-grad-school-in-english-literature-the-economic-financial-and-opportunity-costs/ http://jseliger.wordpress.com/2012/05/22/what-you-should-kno... , and like half a dozen others do in various links from that essay.
If so many people are quitting and/or warning others off the path, there may be a good reason why.
This especially stands out from the article:
Academe is a profession full of erudite free-thinkers who feel disillusioned by a toxic labor system in which criticism is not tolerated—so those who leave often relish the newfound ability to say anything they want (talking about “a friend” here). In its insularity and single-mindedness, academe is also very similar to a fundamentalist religion (or, dare I say, cult), and thus those who abdicate often feel compelled to confess.
"A fundamentalist religion:" if so, each heretic who saves someone else is doing important work. If enough people do so, the message might get out; it certainly has for law schools: http://www.nytimes.com/2012/03/20/business/for-lsat-sharp-drop-in-popularity-for-second-year.html http://www.nytimes.com/2012/03/20/business/for-lsat-sharp-dr....
Anyway, it does seem like academia has grown increasingly exploitative along many measures, especially for workers and grad students. The more people who know before they start, the better.
- mathattack 13y agoThis is actually a good thing, no? If academia is hoarding too many erudite free-thinkers, cut them loose elsewhere to solve the world's problem. If the best 20% of teachers can be leveraged via online resources over 80% of the students, it's ok to have some smart researchers go to the private sector. Automation combined with cost pressure forces re-allocation of resources, and that's fine.
- mjn 13y agoDepends on whether they actually do research in the private sector, though. Historically most fundamental science advances have come either from academia, or from big academia-like research organizations in industry (Bell Labs, Xerox PARC, Microsoft Research), or from government research labs (Sandia, Livermore, CERN, etc.). Most industry R&D tends towards different kinds of problems, applied research with 1-5 years commercialization horizons, sometimes pushing 10. That's a valuable segment of research, but not all of it, and it depends on a pipeline of less-applied research to keep it fed. But due to the difficulty of monetizing indirect future advances that basic science enables, it's difficult to do it profitably in industry. A scientific discovery that at some point in the future turns out to be useful in developing technology is valuable for humanity, but you cannot easily capture that value, as it simply diffuses to the general benefit. Knowledge advances, but anyone can use it, and you don't get to own it; you can get some kind of satisfaction in old age in looking at how this physics discovery you came up with in your 30s is being used to improve chip fabrication processes 40 years later, but you don't get royalties on the chips. Patents try to change that within a 20-year timespan, but they are not supposed to apply to scientific or mathematical discoveries, 20 years is too short for some advances, and they have a whole host of problems anyway.
- mathattack 13y agoI guess I'd divide the research world like this: 1) Pie in the sky research that is beyond the 20 year time horizon of long-view companies and 10 year time horizon of VCs. 2) Research that is amenable to teaching people how to research. 3) Research to advance one's career. 4) Research that is relatively close to Development. There are overlaps, and it can be hard to differentiate between the types until after the fact, but let's go with this model. #1 has to be funded federally (i.e. NSF), via philanthropy (i.e. Gates Foundation) or as a monopoly concession (i.e. Bell Labs). This can belong in the University or elsewhere, and may or may not be tied to teaching. #2 belongs in Universities, as it helps generate the next generation of scholars. #3 should not be financed by taxpayers. It's also hard to justify this in aggregate coming from tuition. Do we really need more papers on Ancient History, or should we invest the same money in better teaching? I understand you need to be an expert to teach, but it seems like a lot of publishing is purely to generate citations. #4 If these people can get real world jobs, why not send them to the real world where rather than stay in a profession with very scarce jobs?
- theOnliest 13y ago> Do we really need more papers on Ancient History, or should we invest the same money in better teaching? This seems to me like a pretty dim view of the humanities in general. Research in the humanities is not in the same category as research in Computer Science, for example; there is often little to no free-market value. People who enter the humanities tend to do so (at least in my experience) because knowledge for the sake of knowledge is something worth pursuing. Your next company might not make a fortune knowing more about agricultural practices of the ancient Macedonians, or the concept of fatherhood in the music of Robert Schumann, but people doing that research aren't doing it simply "to advance their career," and not necessarily just to teach new people how to research either. It has traditionally been the function of universities to foster this sort of research, as a general goal of "making the world a better, more knowledgeable place." It's a societal goal that goes way back: people say that humanity was set back something like 1000 years when the library at Alexandria burned down. This type of research doesn't fit neatly into any of your categories, and it is (I think) a more trenchant problem. Disillusioned humanities PhD's often have problems finding work in the "real world," since companies aren't keen on hiring someone who knows everything there is to know about Macedonian agriculture. -- a fairly disillusioned Ph.D. student in Music Theory
- badman_ting 13y agoI enjoy this short point Zizek makes about the role of intellectuals today. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AdGZeQV4eZc http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AdGZeQV4eZc
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- stevoski 13y agoIn some areas, yes. But your chances of discovering new species of butterflies in the Amazon, climbing Mt Kilimanjaro, finding an apt life partner, producing healthy, well-balanced offspring, having good relations with your parents? In other words, the achievements that matter...have little to do with attending a top university.
- peterwwillis 13y agoTo back this up with an example: If I had a CS degree I could have gotten a job with Amazon years ago, and even farther back than that, could have become the head security bozo for a large state college. I'm still limited in terms of getting the job I want because I just don't have the knowledge to do it yet. Though one should keep in mind the loopholes for non-academic jobs and self-motivation. At my Amazon interview one of the head software bozos actually taught himself everything you'd cover in CS, including all the high-level math. I couldn't hack it, but he did. (edit: the guy I replied to was trying to explain why you need to go)
- bennyg 13y agoExactly. School's great for finding the unknown unknowns - a useful tool even if you're going to teach yourself everything outside of school regardless.
- sillysaurus2 13y agoSorry about that. I deleted my comment after I realized the article was talking about attending grad school, rather than attending university in general, so my comment was talking past the central point and hence didn't apply. I should've made that clear with an edit rather than deleting it, though. It seemed to have no replies when I deleted it (which was three minutes after writing it).
- rmc 13y agoYou will always get people complaining about an industry/professsion. There are lots of people complaining about the tech industry.
- bane 13y agoAmong my personal peer group, all with graduate degrees from good schools at top-of-class GPAs, approximately 0 (zero) have decided to stay in academia. We all know of a few folks who did stay in to pursue a PhD, and the horror stories we heard were more than enough to keep us away. That, and now with all of us in hiring positions and seeing how little it buys in the job market (outside of very few milieus) has confirmed that we'd all rather go back for another Masters or even another Undergraduate degree than go for a PhD in our fields -- some of us already have.
- PaulHoule 13y agoOut of my graduating class of 80 physics PhD's I think one went in academia, a woman.
- louwrentius 13y agoWhy is it relevant that it was a woman? It sounds like you suggest that the only applicant academia got was a 'woman', as if women are mediocre at best.
- jjoonathan 13y agoJust the opposite. We already know that she chose physics even though the prior of being a woman made that choice less likely. We can infer that she was probably more dedicated to the subject itself than her average peer. The fact that she eventually made it in academia supports this hypothesis. Another possibility is that she had a partner willing to support her if things went south. Obviously this situation isn't unique to women, but I do think it's slightly more probable for a woman to have such a partner. If this is the case, PaulHoule's point becomes that the decision to enter grad school only made sense for her because of the artificially reduced consequences of p(failure). Even if affirmative action did play a role (a recent paper found very damning, well-controlled evidence of systematic bias against women in the evaluation process, so I wouldn't assume this with any degree of certainty), PaulHoule could have simply been observing that she saw a better p(success) and was therefore the only one willing to take the leap. Or maybe PaulHoule is a misogynist. But I'd be willing to bet against you if you still thought that.
- drblast 13y ago"In recent months, class-action lawsuits have been filed against more than a dozen law schools, charging that students were snookered into enrolling by postgraduate employment figures that were vastly, and fraudulently, inflated." That's hysterical. Imagine graduating hundreds of students who won't be employed, face a massive amount of debt, and who not only have the skills necessary, but all the time in the world, to sue you for it.
- altoz 13y ago"criticism is not tolerated" These are the people doing research and peer-reviewing? No wonder the quality of research is so bad. Criticism should be encouraged, not suppressed.
- ISL 13y agoCriticism is prevalent in academia, especially with new ideas at the cutting edge. The idea that "criticism is not tolerated" tends to emerge from ideas that fall far from the trunk knowledge of the field. If your new theory of physics comes into direct experimental conflict with the Standard Model, expect to get the cold shoulder. (Actually, at APS meetings and sectional meetings, almost everyone gets a chance to speak. However, not everyone attends the "new perspectives in physics" sub-meeting when there's a talk on another topic in the adjoining room.) This sort of groupthink rejection sees more light when an issue is closer to public policy. In the nascent field of climate science, for example, I wouldn't be surprised to see papers claiming global cooling or stasis rejected almost immediately. Almost everyone in the field these days would appear to believe that global warming is occurring. Coming back to my original thesis; the peer-review process is full of criticism. Search around for web pages aimed exclusively at coaxing young graduate students out of peer-review induced depression. Peer review can be brutal, and the anonymity can double its impact.