3 ms·
I'm going to go from least to most probable here: There's a theory that the nearly last minute requirement that eliminates window shopping was intended to hide
by hga 13y ago
I'm going to go from least to most probable here:
There's a theory that the nearly last minute requirement that eliminates window shopping was intended to hide the ugly details of unsubsidized prices for the new, one size fits all gold-plated plan. Whatever the trade offs in monthly premiums vs. deductibles, the minimum plan has a 10 or so less or non-essential benefits, like covering your children to or through age 26; the old "real insurance" high deductible major medical (catastrophic coverage) plan is soon to be illegal except for around 2 of the 18 million who managed to squeeze through the needle of grandfathering. Letting just anyone window shop would enable a lot of bad press.
It was decided the Federal system was the only one that could calculate subsidies, the state exchanges and insurers have to use it. Whoever does it, this process is absolutely essential to avoid screwing worse many of the above who will lose their insurance come Jan 1 and can't afford the new plans without a subsidy. That, BTW, is the really hard deadline to all this, it's one thing to be changed an already delayed once penalty for not getting insurance, quite another to lose it altogether because your old one was outlawed and the government can't get it's act together to let you buy a one compliant with the new law. And to the extend young whippersnappers feel public spirited enough to buy insurance they don't really need (beyond major medical coverage) so they can help to pay for the 50-64 bracket this system is truly subsidizing, showing them after subsidy prices makes that easier. The initial financials of the system require about 3 million of them out of the total 7 million.
Someone should do a bunch of verification things, and in theory we trust "the government" to do this....
FICO scores are understandably part of new insurance policy pricing (someone's going to be on the hook for when customers don't pay co-pays, deductibles or premiums, so it's an input into pricing), so Experian is checked for yours (which is currently a nightmare for those who don't have one, like sick children who've never really needed to get a credit card etc.; there's supposed to be a process, but it's hard/impossible to get to it on Healthcare.gov or the phone numbers for it).
Credit scores are absolutely tied to real identities, and you can't let just anyone find a particular person's one, directly or indirectly. Only way I can see to have done this differently would still be a stiff identity check and then telling a person what their's is, so they could plug that in along with everything else prior to "window shopping".
I'd note that the current system doesn't allow "what if" games, which due to the subsidy etc. system would be incredibly useful. E.g. the most common advice on how to decrease your Obamacare insurance costs is to make less money. Or someone using a Kaiser? calculator couldn't find any scenario where being married didn't result in higher costs....
- zaroth 13y agoI'm not sure where this FICO score rumor started. Insurance pricing under the ACA can only vary based on your age, zip code of primary residence, and whether or not you admit to smoking tobacco. See: http://www.acscan.org/pdf/healthcare/implementation/background/NewFederalRatingRules.pdf http://www.acscan.org/pdf/healthcare/implementation/backgrou...
- hga 13y agoA quick check with Google shows this cause, since walked back: http://www.weeklystandard.com/blogs/report-credit-score-have-big-impact-how-much-people-pay-obamacare_762318.html http://www.weeklystandard.com/blogs/report-credit-score-have... Yeah, I'm seeing indications that Experian is for some inexplicable reason being tasked with income verification, along with identification verification. I can see the latter, whereas ... well, maybe the IRS just wasn't in a position to do the former at scale, or was otherwise intransigent. They're noted for pretty bad IT after the initial glory days when they first computerized their operations. After the fact the insurance companies can look at customer performance and all sorts of things including individual or aggregate FICO scores to know how to change the overall pricing of their policies going forward. However subsidy levels obviously require more than the three details you mention above, and they're critical for anyone using the system who's entitled to one. A quick check with Google doesn't show any indication FICO scores are used for that.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]