2 ms·
Wow, so much negativity! What happened to the dreams of a computer in your pocket that knew what you wanted to do? All anyone can think of is to complain abou
by nl 13y ago
Wow, so much negativity!
What happened to the dreams of a computer in your pocket that knew what you wanted to do?
All anyone can think of is to complain about privacy? Really?
I once did a brainstorm session with a facilitator who taught me a great technique. Whenever someone suggests something you aren't allowed to so "No" or "But" - instead you should say "Yes" or "And".
Try it for a second:
This application tries to predict what you will need when you pick your phone up. Currently it uses serverside processing to help with that. Yes, and imagine what else it could do with that serverside power! No battery constraints to worry about!
Privacy problems are a great way to kill good ideas. Put those concerns aside for a minute and imagine the portability of handheld devices merged with the power of always-on servers.
- huxley 13y agoYes and privacy problems are still real issues especially as privacy rights are continuously eroded every single day. Just because you wanted something in your pocket to solve all your problems, doesn't mean everyone else did. Many of us wanted a great tool, not a buddy or advisor or mind-reader. Every technological development has many possible routes it can follow, it can't follow them all. And you will inevitably be disappointed at some of the routes it takes. Can you imagine what it must be like to be Richard Stallman or Ted Nelson with a clearly articulated vision of the future but so many things go the other way?
- eternalban 13y ago> What happened to the dreams of a computer in your pocket that knew what you wanted to do? "Yes", the dream lives on; your pocket, your computer, your life -- dream on. "But" this is a for profit business.
- normloman 13y agoI have found the opposite: If you expose your ideas to the criticism of others, you expose flaws in your idea, which leads you to improve the idea. If you don't like something, say no. Say but. Say the truth.
- talmand 13y agoWhy can't this be a good thing with strong privacy protections? What privacy problems are exactly holding it back? I imagine such a tool that collects such information to make things easier as possibly a wonderful thing. I also imagine such a tool that shares all that information with a third party as possibly a horrible thing. I would be willing to go along with your thought, as long as I knew that the information being collected was heavily encrypted and that the only person who would ever get to see it is me. Even then, recent events have shown us that encrypted data on someone else's server is not exactly safe from prying eyes. Don't be so willing to casually toss away your privacy. Once it's gone you may miss it and be unable to get it back.
- nl 13y agoI'm sad to see that EVERY SINGLE REPLY to this comment was "Yes.. but", and the issues raised were exactly the same as in every other thread on this story. I find that more disappointing than the undoubted privacy issues in the application itself. I would note that the privacy issues in this application are no different to those in any other application with a serverside back end. But I guess we feel we need to prove how smart we are by dissecting them.. again.