3 ms·
Nigel Warren Writes: "The fact that iWork on the Mac has lost functionality isn’t because Apple is blind to power users. It’s because they’re willing to ma
by terhechte 13y ago
Nigel Warren Writes:
"The fact that iWork on the Mac has lost functionality isn’t because Apple is blind to power users. It’s because they’re willing to make a short-term sacrifice in functionality so that they can create a foundation that is equal across the Mac, iOS, and web versions. It will take time to bring these new versions of iWork up to parity with what the Mac used to have. In the meantime all platforms have to live with the lowest common denominator."
http://rarebitstudio.com/blog/2013/10/whither-iwork http://rarebitstudio.com/blog/2013/10/whither-iwork
Meaning that Apple had to reduce features to the minimum available on all three platforms and could not support additional features outside of this scope.
However, for some of the removed features, this clearly doesn't make sense:
- Keyboard Shortcuts for text styles. What's the issue with storing shortcuts in the file format that only work on the Mac Version. It's not like they have any influence on the 'looks' of the file
- Selecting non-contiguous text
- Outline View
- Customizable Toolbar
- Reorganize pages by dragging
- Select all instances of style
All these features have no influence of the actual display of the file in question, but only allow for faster editing within the app. Offering any of these features on the Mac version would not influence the usability or display of the data in the iOS or web version. The only actual reason I can think of to omit these features is that they simply had no more time to work on it and had to release in the current state.
- Tyrannosaurs 13y agoSome of those look like things that might have been cut because of time. While most of them are nice, they're all things which are edge cases for most users or potential users. Outline view for example - yes it's a desirable feature but most people just open a document and start typing. Customizing the toolbar is potentially slightly different - that might just be part of Apple's "no need to customize, we've worked out the best way" approach...
- spoondan 13y agoThere's another part of Apple's announcement that may help explain. Apple touts this release as "completely rewritten". Rewriting a complex app often results in a loss of functionality for no better reason than that things are institutionally forgotten. Invisible UX features like page dragging, keyboard shortcuts, etc. seem especially prone to omission by oversight.