9 ms·
EFF Has Lavabit’s Back in Contempt of Court Appeal
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- thex86 13y agoSo, how does one fight a contempt of court? Is it even possible? (PS: Great job EFF!)
- rhizome 13y agoI'm guessing it involves appealing (or similar) the court order that the contempt finding depends on.
- alttag 13y agoYes. Lavabit's filing [0] is to the Fourth District Court of Appeals. Page 1 of their brief (after all of the disclosures and tables of content) explains the jurisdictional stuff pretty well. 0: [pdf] http://cdn.arstechnica.net/wp-content/uploads/2013/10/gov.uscourts.ca4_.13-4625.26.0.pdf http://cdn.arstechnica.net/wp-content/uploads/2013/10/gov.us...
- einhverfr 13y agoBravo, EFF. Seriously, that is one heck of a broad warrant, namely the private key used to decrypt all business records of all customers.
- dingaling 13y agoThe warrant was specifically for the data relating to Mr Snowden. Go and read the disclosed documents: that is the only individual on whom data was requested. There was no warrant for the SSL keys; that was issued as a subpoena when Mr Levison stated that the data-in-transit was encrypted. The judge told him to disclose the keys that were protecting Mr Snowden's data. That Mr Levison happened to use the same SSL certs for all paying customers isn't the fault of anyone but... him.
- enry_straker 13y agoNow, the courts get to decide how to run your business?
- AnkhMorporkian 13y agoWhen they have a warrant? Absolutely they do. They've always had that power, and every country I know of has warrants of similar power. If you're hosting encrypted data that focuses on privacy while remaining law abiding, it's just sensible to maintain separate SSL keys so you avoid this very scenario. It's not as if it wasn't foreseeable.
- lsiebert 13y agoDoesn't separate ssl certd allow someone to know which user is using the service?
- adekok 13y agoYes. If you have separate server certs per user (as suggested above), then you can tell which user is using the service. If you have separate client certs per user, then you call tell which user is using the service. The Lavabit response to the original order was not the best, IMHO. As he was in possession of the certs and private keys, he could have decrypted Snowdon's traffic himself, and handed it to the court. Instead, he tried to hide behind a BS "it's encrypted" defence. The court called his bluff. He lost.
- talmand 13y agoI thought he offered to do that and they turned him down? I would imagine him decrypting the data himself would cause problems in a chain-of-evidence type of way though.
- lsiebert 13y agohmm... is there a way to obfuscate that to the outside? Can you wrap the individual certs? Or use the same cert for everyone, but do a zero knowledge key exchange for people who want to log in, and then have them authenticate with a signed document keyed to a public key they gave when they signed up for the service? Anyway, at least in the physical security industry, security isn't about preventing intrusions. It is about delaying it and limiting it until a sufficient response can be mobilized. Perfect security is impossible
- chris_mahan 13y agoAnd there is still doubt we live in a police state?
- csense 13y agoAt least the issue is being discussed in public and litigated in the courts.
- pdkl95 13y ago...and wouldn't it be nice, if we could actually stop this kind of problem before it became something the courts dare not touch, spoken of only with rare whispers. Those types of situations historically end up rather nasty for all involved. It's probably a bad sign when the sane legal solution to avoid a rebellion (or worse) seems like fanciful wishful thinking. edit: As other have said: Thank you, EFF!
- einhverfr 13y agoIt was litigated in the courts in the USSR too. Not so much discussed in public but I am not sure that matters. The whole issue of making such a taboo topic is that it makes it hard for opposition to mobilize. However in the US we have other ways of doing that. Hyperpartisanship is something which has a remarkably similar effect while at the same time allowing us to say with a straight face that we are not a police state.....
- simonh 13y agoI'm afraid this is what you get when you architect your political system to institutionalize gerrymandering. I suspect that hyperpartisanship, and the thorough political dysfunction we're seeing over in the US at the moment, is pretty much an unavoidable consequence of developing very stable partisan electoral ghettos. In the UK such gerrymandering is taken very seriously because it's a fundamental attack on the integrity of the electoral system. People found guilty of it have had their political and personal lives ruined, and quite rightly too. But in the US it's standard practice. I don't think this is taken seriously enough.
- csense 13y agoIt's interesting that the two strongest practical arguments EFF is making (based on how people will react to an adverse decision) are also the two that probably the least persuasive from a legal standpoint (based on laws and court precedents). I'm talking about service providers moving their operations to more privacy-friendly jurisdictions, and improving protocols with e.g. perfect forward secrecy to make this sort of attack impractical. So everyone suffers under an adverse decision in this case: The US economy suffers because businesses seriously concerned about privacy choose to locate elsewhere Law enforcement suffers because those businesses are no longer reachable when they have a legitimate reason to obtain the communications of spies, terrorists, or plain old criminals, and get a narrow warrant that properly protects the privacy of innocent bystanders. Individual liberty suffers because a precedent will make it easier for people who don't care about privacy and use domestic providers subject to these overbroad warrants to be caught up in a surveillance dragnet That being said, Congress, not the courts, is the proper venue to address those practical arguments. Will anyone care outside of technophile bubbles like HN? Unfortunately, I think we all know the answer.
- doug1001 13y agonice one, EFF--you guys are bad ass. EFF has of course also for the past decade, been a relentless warrior against Patent Trolls. i don't know, but i would be willing to bet, that the new troll-killing bill is in part due to their efforts as well.
- AsymetricCom 13y agoEFF is a pointless figurehead that does none of it's own work. It simply coopts ongoing legal action and puts their name on it anyway they can. This is a pointless case, like the EFF can fix https by this case? No, the cat is already out of the bag. https has been broken for some time, first by cyber criminals and businesses being stupid, and then the NSA trying to keep up with the game.
- alttag 13y agoGlad the EFF is joining. For background, Lavabit filed their appeal a few weeks ago [0]. Ars covered it [1], and it was discussed here on HN [2] as well. 0: [pdf] http://cdn.arstechnica.net/wp-content/uploads/2013/10/gov.uscourts.ca4_.13-4625.26.0.pdf http://cdn.arstechnica.net/wp-content/uploads/2013/10/gov.us... 1: http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2013/10/lavabits-appeal-were-actually-not-required-to-wiretap-our-own-users/ http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2013/10/lavabits-appeal-w... 2: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6531814 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6531814
- theinterjection 13y agoWhy did Levison have access to their users mails in the first place? Didn't they claim that only you can see your emails? Isn't that the reason you can't reset your password?