2 ms·
Oh wow.. From my point of view the point here is the "Chinese Wall"[1] that used to exist between organic results and paid advertising. That used to be clearl
by nl 13y ago
Oh wow..
From my point of view the point here is the "Chinese Wall"[1] that used to exist between organic results and paid advertising.
That used to be clearly defined, and the trust that came from that was one of Google's strengths.
The way the "Sponsored" result hides the organic result for [Southwest Airlines] (by scrolling it off the page) makes that wall redundant - effectively Google is being paid for any click there. Or that's what I think anyway: your comment "the navigational ad and the first organic result are combined" makes me think that Google is actually combining paid and organic results without labelling them separately at all. In that case the "Chinese Wall" is gone completely.
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_wall http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_wall
- kbenson 13y agoTo me, it just looks like southwest paid money to put a picture on top of the (awesome, IMO) google provided first result and deep links into relevant sections of the first result site. I'm always pleasantly surprised when I search for a site and get nav links into it's main sections, because it's invariably much easier to navigate than the site's own navigational system. I have no problem letting Google sell a little extra space above this nav section, especially since it only seems to appear when the result returned are related predominantly that that first site. I.e. Google doesn't appear to be doing this for the search "airlines", but does as soon as the search is definitive enough to identity a specific airline.