5 ms·
McDonald's Tells Its Employees to Sign Up for Food Stamps
- Noughmad 13y agoIt's pretty simple. There will be low-paying jobs as long as people are willing to work there. McDonald's knows there is more than enough job candidates, so there is no reason for them to raise wages.
- Pitarou 13y agoWhence the call to raise the minimum wage.
- ck2 13y agoWalmart does this too. And don't even whisper the word "union" in walmart, they have an emergency legal team that flys into any location where there is even a hint of a union forming. This is why people should not fight against a decent minimum wage, because otherwise all taxpayers are subsidizing the below-standard income. Yes, your items might cost a penny more in the store.
- dchest 13y agoWhy does the government issue food stamps to people who have jobs?
- lmm 13y agoBecause the US minimum wage is so low that many people with (probably part-time, remember) jobs can't reasonably live on it.
- d4mi3n 13y agoBecause those same people are unable to make enough money to feed themselves and their families working multiple part-time/full-time jobs paying these sorts of wages.
- dchest 13y agoIsn't it circular: workers are able to take jobs that pay less than [imaginary] minimum wage because government will subsidize their survival --> government subsidizes low-paying workers --> businesses can hire for less then minimum wage --> etc? What's the cause and what's the effect?
- qwerty989 13y agoWrong. http://cdn.theatlantic.com/static/mt/assets/business/Screen%20Shot%202013-03-07%20at%203.54.49%20PM.png http://cdn.theatlantic.com/static/mt/assets/business/Screen%...
- dchest 13y agoHow do you interpret this chart?
- qwerty989 13y agoThe poor in America spend a small percentage of their income on food. http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2013/03/cheap-eats-how-america-spends-money-on-food/273811/ http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2013/03/cheap-ea...
- dchest 13y agoThanks! I haven't yet read the article you linked to, so maybe the answer is already there, but does this chart include food stamps for poor? I mean, is it (stamps + 16.1% of income)?
- smtddr 13y agoSo, because of this article you conclude that the OP is wrong to say poor people are "unable to make enough money to feed themselves and their families working multiple part-time/full-time jobs paying these sorts of wages."? Maybe they spend less because they simply can't afford to spend more? I spend less on private-jets & high-end cars than rich people do, is it because I simply don't want those items or because I can't afford it? Actually, this article appears to be saying the opposite of what you think it's saying: FTA: The short answer is that relative food costs are low and falling fast for everybody -- but they're not falling for the poor. In 1984, the poorest Americans spent 16 percent of their income to eat. The median-income family also spent 16 percent of its (slightly higher) income on food. And the rich spent the least. In the last three decades, food's share of the family budget has fallen for all but the poorest families, where it's stayed the same. So... poor people are spending _more_ on food than the rich? Whatever way one interprets this article, I don't think it can be used to to prove anything in regards to affordability of food for the poor and what else they may have sacrificed to pay for food.
- KingMe 13y agoWorking poor. It's a real problem.
- joshAg 13y agofood stamp eligibility is based on whether you live at or below the poverty line. Minimum wage, while once above the poverty line (assuming a 40 hour work week), has not risen with inflation, so it is now well below the poverty line.
- ck2 13y agoVirtually all states now require you to be working or looking for work to get food stamps if you are not legally disabled. People loafing around while getting food stamps does not really exist in the USA for a decade or more now.
- qwerty989 13y agoThis argument is deeply flawed. What if they were unemployed? Taxpayers would be subsidizing a lot more.
- kelnos 13y agoWhy would they be unemployed? It's hard to make the argument that McDonald's (and similar) would make cuts to its work force if the minimum wage were higher, considering their profits are already ridiculously healthy.
- WettowelReactor 13y agoMcDonalds has about about 1.7 Million employee's. For arguments sake lets round that down 10 1.5 Million. Assume none of them work full time, in-fact lets say they work 1/3 of a full time job so about 700 hours a year. That's just over 1 Billion labor hours a year. Now they make about 5 Billion in profit so just how much more pay can they squeeze out of that? Every dollar increase in base pay would shrink profits by 20%.
- cperciva 13y agoI don't understand what the problem is here. McDonald's is trying to help its employees access government services to which they are entitled. This seems like a very good thing; all the more so given that Mcdonald's disproportionately employs minorities and individuals with low levels of education -- both groups which historically encounter "paperwork challenges" in accessing government services.
- simfoo 13y agoYou don't see a problem when a very profitable franchise tells its employees to ask the government for support because it doesn't want to pay them enough to live off? This is disgusting.
- stevoski 13y agoIs McDonald's really very profitable? I ask innocently, I don't live in America, I never eat in McDonald's, and I think you are probably right, but I'm seeking data to back up the assertion. If McDonald's arbitrarily raised wages, could they do that without increasing the costs of their products? Would that then make them less competitive against the horde of other fast food shops, and therefore reduce their sales dramatically in what may (or may not, I really don't know) be a hyper-competitive industry. These are the types of considerations I'm sure are important.
- dchest 13y agoFrom Wikipedia article: Revenue US$27.56 billion (2012) Operating income US$8.60 billion (2012) Net income US$5.46 billion (2012) Total assets US$35.39 billion (2012) Total equity US$15.29 billion (2012) Employees 1,800,000 (2013)
- stevoski 13y agoI think that works out to $3000/employee. If these employees work on average 2000 hours/year (could be wildly different to that, depends on how many of these employees are full-time, and the amount of hours in a full-time work year in various countries), and McDonalds was to pay each employee $1/hour more, the profits would drop by two-thirds, to $1000/employee. Without raising price, some franchises could eat[1] that extra cost; some would probably have to close shop. [1] Boom. Zing.
- JonnieCache 13y agoSimilarly, the second largest chunk of the UK welfare payouts goes to the working poor, at 20.8%. Payments to the unemployed are at 2.57%. The government brings this constant drip-drip of poisonous rhetoric about scroungers, when what's really happening is the ultra-rich are scrounging from the middle class to subsidise their empires while keeping the poor mentally broken and unable to form a political force. I should really start some sort of PR campaign, there's an election next year. Data: http://www.ifs.org.uk/bns/bn13.pdf http://www.ifs.org.uk/bns/bn13.pdf
- arethuza 13y agoBut that 2.57% is still £5.164 billion a year - which is rather a lot of money. Mind you, I take your point - from the way that the problem is described by the Daily Mail crowd (ironically, in my experience, often retired people) you'd think that 90% of welfare payments were going to the unemployed.
- anon1385 13y ago>I should really start some sort of PR campaign, there's an election next year. Nice try but the toffs are one step ahead of you and are banning such political campaigns in an election year: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transparency_of_Lobbying,_Non-party_Campaigning_and_Trade_Union_Administration_Bill https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transparency_of_Lobbying,_Non-... https://secure.38degrees.org.uk/page/m/74c04b7f/2d565a2f/52107803/4669ffc2/214504013/VEsE/ https://secure.38degrees.org.uk/page/m/74c04b7f/2d565a2f/521... Campaigns could fall within regulation if they: -promote policies which, for whatever reason, are associated with one or more political parties or candidates – such as housing, welfare, a referendum on EU membership, wind farms or HS2. As you might imagine a huge range of campaign groups and charities are up in arms about this.
- qwerta 13y agoThere is other side of this: McDonald care about its employees. I wish someone would give me advice like this, when I used to work at similar place. Articles like this will only cause stricter rules and food stamps will go away. Sure minimum wage should be better, but ask yourself: how often do you leave a tip at a fast food?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- Osiris 13y agoMcDonalds made $1.52 billion in profit last quarter. [1] I do think that it's irresponsible for the company to rely on the government to subsidize their employees, especially considering their profits. [1] http://stream.wsj.com/story/markets/SS-2-5/SS-2-359306/ http://stream.wsj.com/story/markets/SS-2-5/SS-2-359306/
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- dchest 13y agoWhy is it irresponsible?
- Osiris 13y agoThe company isn't absorbing the true cost of doing business. Many businesses have problems like this, like coal power plants that dump CO2 into the air. They don't have to pay the costs of dealing with their actions. Tobacco companies don't have to pay for health care when people get sick from their product. This shifts part of the cost of doing business onto someone else, thus distorting their market.
- stevoski 13y agoI went to university in Australia; there McDonald's et al employed primarily high-school and university students. The feeling was that a fast food job was something you did part-time while studying. The employees are generally people on the way up to a degree and a career. Some of these people were also on welfare; specifically a government program that augments the income of students from not-too-wealthy households. I then visited the US, and was surprised to find a completely different group of employees at fast food chains. The staff seemed to be older, more permanently in the fast food industry, and often seemed like they had been beaten down by the daily drudge of many years.
- gadders 13y agoWhen I was a student, 20+ years ago, I had a summer job in America selling aerial photos door to door. I got chatting to an older guy serving in a MacDonalds who asked me a lot of questions about what cameras were used etc etc. I told him he knew a lot about cameras, and he said "I used to be a professional photographer, but I went out of business. Now it's either this or suicide." Poor bastard. I always wondered what happened to him and I hope he got back on his feet.
- stevoski 13y agoNow that is one terse but powerful anecdote.
- ChrisNorstrom 13y agoHe lives in the USA and he thinks his only options are McDonalds or Suicide? That is the true definition of a sad loser. There's billions of people who wish they had the same opportunities he had. People dye trying to sneak into this country through shipping containers and makeshift rafts and he's already here and unable to weigh the endless options he has. From Target to Walmart, Kmart to Macy's, Taco Bell to Burger King, Gas Stations to Jiffy Lubes... I'm sorry, I just can't feel sorry for him. There's too many other people in worse situations, in worse countries, who deserve more sympathy.
- 13y ago
- room271 13y agoSet a minimum wage to a reasonable level (i.e. enough that you can eat without extra support if earning it) and the issue goes away. The idea that you can shame companies into action doesn't work - it might in one or two cases, but people quickly forget, and there are too many companies to target anyway.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- kubiiii 13y agoIf profits are reasonable and workers still have to sign up for food stamps, maybe the price of food at mac donalds is too cheap. So taxpayer are subsidizing both profits and cheap food. They also subsidize it through healthcare for ppl eating too much mac donalds. A few decades ago, people would spend roughly one third of their income for food. How much do we spend now? Far less.