3 ms·
One of the Good things about autonomous cars is that we're close to having cars that can drive, when people want them to succeed. One of the bad things is that
by ChuckMcM 13y ago
One of the Good things about autonomous cars is that we're close to having cars that can drive, when people want them to succeed. One of the bad things is that messing with them will be too over powering to resist and that will slow their deployment.
The typical "mess with this" kind of action would be walk up on the edge of a freeway and pop up a full sized STOP sign on the shoulder. Humans will say 'wtf?' and keep driving but autonomous cars, unable to know if it isn't a legit stop sign, will slam on the brakes to stop. Resulting in hugely funny (to some) traffic jams. Similarly with inflatable stoplights.
Then there are the things where even human drivers have issues (a person standing on the side of the road signalling traffic to slow down).
There are many situations that autonomous cars will need to be able to handle, that are handled in a fail safe way today by humans, yet to be programmed. Definitely will take longer than you think.
- SEJeff 13y agoAnd something tells me that would be made very illegal assuming it isn't now (which it most likely is) very very quickly. It would be funny until it got someone killed. Then, not so much
- jpatokal 13y agoMessing with traffic signs is, unsurprisingly, already very illegal.
- nl 13y agoThree defendants were sentenced to 15 years each in state prison Friday for uprooting a stop sign at an intersection where three teen-agers were killed in a crash a few hours later. http://edition.cnn.com/US/9706/20/stop.sign/ http://edition.cnn.com/US/9706/20/stop.sign/
- tomlu 13y agoI would have thought in the future all kinds of traffic circumstances would be handled by broadcasting information (such as "slow down") in a format native to the onboard computer. Then the guy in the hi-vis suit is just a redundancy for humans.
- avn2109 13y agoBut then our pranksters will merely hack together a parabolic dish and Raspberry Pi to emit faux stop-sign signals, then set up shop on the nearest mountaintop and snipe Benz's for fun. So now this is a signing/crypto and signal reliability problem, which is a bit harder. But still doable.
- ignostic 13y agoEasier said than done. What happens when the power goes out to the city's system? Can we trust the city to keep traffic info up-to-date? What happens when there's too much interference? When you're in a tunnel with the roads broadcasting above you? Self-driving cars are the future, but these solutions that seem simple will still need a lot of work.
- derefr 13y agoMemristor RFID chips. The cars have to be powered to move -- so you get the cars to ping road-embedded sensors, which then respond with the latest value they've been programmed with. They could get get programmed either over the 'net, or by a maintenance truck passing by and pinging them with a cryptographically signed message.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- Smirnoff 13y ago>> The typical "mess with this" kind of action would be walk up on the edge of a freeway and pop up a full sized STOP sign on the shoulder. I am pretty sure, these autonomous cars will get info about road signs, etc through an authorized satellite system. So you can pop up with whatever sign you want, it is not going to matter.