6 ms·
In Denmark, they prevent infections in chicken houses by thoroughly cleaning them, then using techniques developed for clean rooms to prevent infections. In the
by stcredzero 13y ago
In Denmark, they prevent infections in chicken houses by thoroughly cleaning them, then using techniques developed for clean rooms to prevent infections. In the US, we let them wade in their own filth and pump them full of antibiotics. We should just make it flat out illegal to use antibiotics across entire herds of livestock. We should also fine doctors for prescribing antibiotics to patients with a viral infection and no sign of bacteria in their systems, unless they are severely immune compromised.
- carbocation 13y agoAs you can imagine, doctors initially got into trouble with this because there is no test that you can use in clinic that says "this patient just has a viral infection". Nevertheless, there are clinical criteria that we can use to come to the same conclusion, and the tide changed years ago with regards to inappropriate antibiotic use for routine viral illnesses. It gets much dicier in-hospital when someone has a SIRS response and you need to presumptively treat them for sepsis. I would be curious to know: of the antibiotic resistance burden that comes from human antibiotic use (specifically in countries where abx are physician-prescribed and not available over the counter), how much of this burden comes from broad treatment of presumed serious infections, and how much comes from treatment of presumed non-serious infections or even postsurgical prophylaxis?
- XorNot 13y agoResistance is a funny thing: there's nothing specifically wrong with going nuts with the antibiotics provided everything gets dead. The problem is much more with people who only take partial courses or are non-compliant, because if you don't clear the infection then round 2 is full of the slightly more resistant members of the species.
- carbocation 13y agoSure, but my question is about epidemiology. Rather than assuming that most resistance comes from "bad"/noncompliant/non-adherent/choose-your-euphemism patients, it would be interesting to know what the current burden of resistance can actually be attributed to (separating out resistance due to livestock antibiosis, countries where people can just buy antibiotics over the counter, etc).
- MaysonL 13y agoThere's also, of course, all the antibiotics that go into sewers.
- hershel 13y ago>>there is no test that you can use in clinic that says "this patient just has a viral infection" I believe there are some labs-on-chip that can detect multiple(even thousands) bacteria and/or viruses. I'm not sure if they are in commercial usage.
- rodw 13y agoThe function of antibiotics in agriculture isn't to prevent infection (or at least, not primarily to prevent infection) but to fatten the animals up for slaughter.
- dylandrop 13y agoI still don't think that justifies the use of them.
- rodw 13y agoNor do I. I'm just pointing out that the antibiotics aren't strictly being used for disease-prevention (hence better hygiene alone might not eliminate their use).
- aestra 13y agoHow exactly does antibiotics fatten animals up for slaughter?
- shabble 13y agoThe obvious answer is: You can't profitably slaughter diseased animals (at least for human consumption, with various complex exemptions that massively reduce value) So treating with broad-spec antibiotic prophylaxis increases your healthy-at-slaughter-date yield, especially under cost-optimised industrial feedlots. More incrementally, (if perhaps still somewhat controversially), normal gut bacteria accounts for some fraction of the energy intake provided by animal feed. By killing them off, it frees up nutrients for the host. Other mechanisms including reduced immune load may also be involved. Quoting from [1]: > According to the National Office of Animal Health (NOAH, 2001), antibiotic growth promoters are used to "help growing animals digest their food more efficiently, get maximum benefit from it and allow them to develop into strong and healthy individuals". Although the mechanism underpinning their action is unclear, it is believed that the antibiotics suppress sensitive populations of bacteria in the intestines. It has been estimated that as much as 6 per cent of the net energy in the pig diet could be lost due to microbial fermentation in the intestine (Jensen, 1998). If the microbial population could be better controlled, it is possible that the lost energy could be diverted to growth. [1] http://www.fao.org/docrep/article/agrippa/555_en.htm http://www.fao.org/docrep/article/agrippa/555_en.htm
- ataggart 13y ago>We [sic] should just make it flat out illegal to... >We [sic] should also fine doctors for... Why is violence an appropriate response to these non-violent issues?
- kintamanimatt 13y agoThat's not violence. They're not being beaten with a crowbar.
- ctdonath 13y agoIt's the threat thereof that persuades compliance. If you try hard enough to do & keep doing something illegal, there is no limit which the state is unwilling to go to in coercing compliance.
- kintamanimatt 13y agoNobody's gonna beat a vet with a rubber hose because they gave a cow antibiotics.
- meepmorp 13y agoIt's your basic (American, right-) libertarian argument against the state doing anything that limits business. I think its application in a case like this nicely encapsulates the flaws in the philosophy, or at least the ability of its adherents to apply it sensibly. Edit for clarity.
- kintamanimatt 13y agoWhat? How did you make that leap from "nobody's gonna beat a vet with a rubber hose" to assuming I'm a hardcore libertarian? I'm for the reduction of antibiotics through government regulation. I think business should be restricted when it comes to doing harm to society. With such a leap, I can only logically assume you replied to the wrong comment.
- gcb0 13y agoBut then the chicken breast price increase will be passed to the consumers! keep the government out of my money! (just trying to keep the discourse here as balanced as it would be if this discussion was out of HN)