3 ms·
This is very serious. But consider the worst-case outcome: No more anti-biotics, for anyone. That is, we go back to the era before anti-biotics, life in the
by javajosh 13y ago
This is very serious. But consider the worst-case outcome:
No more anti-biotics, for anyone.
That is, we go back to the era before anti-biotics, life in the 1920's. Maybe mortality rates will go back to that era, and maybe higher. But thankfully we aren't talking about a plague. At least not yet.
Recently I had a wisdom tooth extracted. The dentist prescribed anti-biotics, but (unknown to him) I didn't take them. I healed fine. And so it was in the 20's and before that. Plenty of people survived and thrived before anti-biotics. And life will go on when we don't have them anymore.
No doubt these super bugs have had to give up certain advantages to attain what is (for their species) a very specialized survival mechanism. Which means that if we ease off of the drugs for a while, the bacterial populations will compete, and the less drug resistant ones will thrive. Then we can use our drugs again. Or that's the idea.
What I'd really like to see are the internal assessments of big pharma of these gram neg bugs. Why isn't it economically feasible to create new drugs for them? This article makes it sound like there is a large and growing market of suffering people who'd be more than willing to spend every last cent for a pill to make the pain go away. And if the prospect of people willingly bankrupting themselves for drugs doesn't perk big pharma's interest, I don't know what would.
- roc 13y ago> "Why isn't it economically feasible to create new drugs for them? " It's not that you couldn't make a profit off them. It's that the opportunity costs can't be justified (today). There's a finite amount of R&D funds available to any firm. And if I'm maximizing profit, I'm not going to spend my money on difficult research, seeking and developing a drug useful to a handful of patients in 4% of hospitals, that's taken for a few weeks by each patient. Not if I can instead spend it tweaking known drugs, useful to 30-50% of the entire population, that they'll take for the rest of their lives. (e.g. blood pressure medicine) And particularly not when CDC, WHO, et al are actively campaigning for changes to antibiotic handling/prescription/use which may well mean your potential future market for "a better antibiotic" is actually smaller than today's.
- klmr 13y agoI think you seriously underestimate just how many lives antibiotics save. Sure, for your tooth extraction they were completely unnecessary and your doctor is either a bit of an idiot or there were other compelling reasons to suspect that antibiotics might be beneficial. But healthcare-wise I would not want to go back to the 1920, no sir. Without antibiotics, medical routine procedures will become life-threatening again (that said, I don’t share the article’s pessimism; yes, it’s bad – but there will be solutions).