3 ms·
> and they're harmless In the same way that shouting "fire" or "gun" in the same situation is harmless. If someone does any of these things and panic a crowd w
by dspillett 13y ago
> and they're harmless
In the same way that shouting "fire" or "gun" in the same situation is harmless. If someone does any of these things and panic a crowd who then hurt themselves rushing to get out of the area, they should be expecting at least some wrist slapping in exchange for their little jape.
> I can't get worked up over it, though.
I think what we have here is a high performing autist, either that or some form of sociopath: very intelligent and articulate, but decidedly lacking in empathy.
- Robin_Message 13y ago> I think what we have here is a high performing autist, either that or some form of sociopath: very intelligent and articulate, but decidedly lacking in empathy. The whole point of what Schneider has spent years writing and talking to the media about is security theatre etc. He is constantly trying to explain and encourage people to make risk decisions rationally, not emotionally. Characturing slightly, he is the opposite of the national-security loving ideologue who sounds sincere and caring, but really wants people to be more scared, because that gives them more power (consciously or not). Or do you think a more empathetic presentation is what is needed? For example, should he be saying something more like "A loud bang is undoubtedly scary in an airport, but there was no actual threat to life and the existing security systems caught the person, so I am personally very relaxed about this non-issue, and I feel others should be too." I could definitely see more empathy being helpful in his presentation, but his core message is good.
- alanctgardner2 13y ago> who then hurt themselves rushing to get out of the area > at least some wrist slapping The potential sentence is 6 years. Nobody was actually hurt.
- dspillett 13y ago> Nobody was actually hurt Physically, no. It probably put the willies up some people though! And some could easily have been physically injured. Have you ever seen a crowd of concerned people trying to leave somewhere? It isn't always a pretty, calm, and organised situation. If you only punish people when damage is actually done then you do not discourage silly-but-potentially-damaging actions: you simply make it an extra gamble which for some increases the buzz the prankster gets out of the game. To compare the situation to a more common situation where people are punished for damage the potentially could have done (but in the instance in question, didn't): If I were to drive at 100mph through a 20mph zone around a school while a little over the legal alcohol limit I would not be let off the punishments for speeding and drink driving if I didn't actually hurt anyone or damage any property. A great many people speed daily and a fair few drink+drive on a regular basis: many are surprised how few actual problems (deaths, injuries, damage to property) are caused as a result hence the oft heard refrain "I've always driven this way and never had a problem yet". "yet" is the operative word there. The first time there is a problem it could be a very serious one and the punishments for these actions take this into account and are intended to discourage the actions generally to reduce the many thousands of instances so that the "1-in-lots" chance is less of a concern. Also even without injuries there is a issue of wasted time and resource both from the passengers point of view and the airport and authorities. On that point I like the suggestion someone else made above that pranksters are fined to cover any disturbance and clean-up costs, though I imagine that could be expensive to enforce (who decides what a legitimate amount is? who does it get handed out to? how arduous would the appeals processes be for the prankster and the relevant agencies if they think they are not getting enough?). > The potential sentence is 6 years But that isn't the actual sentence yet is it? Lets see what sort of slap is eventually handed out before we pass judgement on it.
- venomsnake 13y agoWell my opinion - fine the guy with the bomb squad response cost not jail. This will be a hefty sum and will definitely discourage other pranksters but will show that there is at least some sober heads in the government on security questions. You caused disturbance - you pay for it. But going to jail without doing any damage to anything or anyone is absurd.
- diydsp 13y agoYes I agree with the empathy part. Bruce is getting deservedly high profile views nowadays. A little empathy would lubricate the gears of his cause yet wouldn't violate his principles at all. It's got to have been a headache for the security people at LAX and all the travelers. And while it wasn't an act of terrorism, it sure was a major fucking nuisance, probably delaying all kinds of flights. And it should be punished. As for cameras at LAX, weren't they warranted, even way before this? I can see Bruce not wanting to add cameras as a reaction to this, but aren't they worthwhile in any large area?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- baddox 13y agoThe reason that shouting "fire" is considered dangerous isn't because people get scared, but rather that people tend to stampede, which actually gets people physically harmed or killed. The analogy of "shouting BOO in a theater" doesn't carry quite the same weight.