3 ms·
>requires vast and increasing amounts of the world's energy "Vast" is hyperbole, IMHO. It might in fact on net conserve energy, by, e.g., reducing the need to
by hollerith 13y ago
>requires vast and increasing amounts of the world's energy
"Vast" is hyperbole, IMHO. It might in fact on net conserve energy, by, e.g., reducing the need to haul cash around in armored vehicles and the need for things like bank buildings. It takes a lot of energy to build and operate buildings.
- plumbzium 13y agoIn the classical economy spirit one could expect that the mining power supply and demand will be optimized by the invisible hand of the market. It seems to me too that there might be less costs and negative externalities implicitly bound to bitcoin operation as compared to paper money.
- betterunix 13y agoFor Bitcoin to be secure, you always need more energy to be devoted to honest mining than is devoted to an attack -- and that ignores the energy spent securing Bitcoin wallets (which is fine to ignore, as it is tiny by comparison). In the limit, half the energy output of the entire planet would have to be devoted to Bitcoin for it to remain secure, though I doubt that any economy could sustain such a situation. By comparison maintaining security for paper money requires substantially less energy than attacking paper money, even if you include the energy devoted to fighting theft (the analog of the energy devoted to securing individual Bitcoin wallets). The energy spent on counterfeiting detection is far lower than the energy needed to counterfeit modern paper money, and Chaum showed the world how to create digital cash that is even more secure against counterfeiting, with security against double spending, and that allows for anonymous transactions, while still requiring far less energy to be spent on security than would be needed to attack the system. So no, there is no hyperbole here. Bitcoin is a very inefficient system. It might work in practice, but that does not make it efficient, nor does it even make it an improvement over what we have now. The only think Bitcoin has going for it is that there is no obvious central authority (I say no obvious central authority because in practice, the Bitcoin developers have as much power over the currency as a central bank -- they can e.g. cause a block chain fork at any time, as they accidentally did a few months ago).
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]