2 ms·
I appreciate that feedback, but I actually added that "prediction" after the value on the comment reached -2. So I am pretty sure it was because people disagree
by EGreg 13y ago
I appreciate that feedback, but I actually added that "prediction" after the value on the comment reached -2. So I am pretty sure it was because people disagreed with my stance, as I had provided a bunch of thoughtful reasoning besides simply stating my opinion and the comment was inviting reasonable discussion.
So I decided to call out this phenomenon and make this a genuine test of whether I would be downvoted simply because people disagreed with my position, WITHOUT discussing it first. But sadly it was contaminated by people like you downvoting because I had violated a guideline. I guess in retrospect it wasn't that productive to do it.
- jnbiche 13y agoTwo things: 1. If you really wanted to make it a test of downvoting, you should have discussed the phenomenon in another thread (although I would have downvoted you in that thread, since any discussion of being downvoted flouts HN guidelines). 2. You should have given it a chance, even after two downvotes. It's not unusual to receive one or two quick downvotes and then be upvoted back to full visibility if you're comment is unpopular but rational, unemotional, and no ad hominems or other personal attacks. For one, I would have upvoted it. In my experience, it's rare to see good but unpopular arguments downvoted to reduced visibility after the initial 20-30 mins.