5 ms·
If anything to like about Bitcoin is that it has proved that almost everyone else is wrong. * SilkRoad shutting down? Bitcoin is doomed. * Mt.gox is not payin
by csomar 13y ago
If anything to like about Bitcoin is that it has proved that almost everyone else is wrong.
* SilkRoad shutting down? Bitcoin is doomed.
* Mt.gox is not paying in time or at all? Bitcoin doesn't work.
* Asics? There will be a flood of new coins.
And yet Bitcoin value continue to raise. If history repeats itself, we should see 1 Bitcoin levels at around $2,000.
I think Bitcoin is an interesting phenomena to watch. Being too solid for the quakes that it got, means it's going to stay for a longer period.
I'll be just watching, meanwhile.
- exit 13y ago> Asics? There will be a flood of new coins.* the rate of production is fixed, so no one would have predicted that. asic would increase the difficulty level significantly though.
- mayneack 13y agoBeing wrong rarely stops people from predicting things
- gwern 13y ago>the rate of production is fixed, so no one would have predicted that. IIRC, the arguments actually went that GPU miners had their equipment already paid for, and so could afford to hoard their mined coins, but that ASIC miners, who were paying thousands of dollars for their equipment, would be forced to sell their coins immediately to pay for their equipment & electricity.
- bdcravens 13y agoI'd dare say the majority of GPU miners did invest in new equipment. I'd venture that there were plenty of nerds who were interested in mining that didn't already have rigs with decent GPUs already.
- waterlesscloud 13y agoThis isn't quite right. The rate of production has increased, because the computing power is increasing at a very high rate between difficulty adjustments. Blocks are being solved faster than they are "supposed" to be, statistically. It won't last, eventually the increase in computing power will taper off, but that's the state of things at the moment.
- ap22213 13y agoIt's not surprising that it's rising in value. People are holding on to ~12M coins (worth approx. $2.4B) and are hyping it up so that more people buy them. The more people that buy them, the more the price will go up, the more that they'll be worth, the more that people will buy them....
- dingaling 13y agoHmm, there are fewer than 12 million Bitcoins in existence. https://blockchain.info/charts/total-bitcoins https://blockchain.info/charts/total-bitcoins I'm certainly hoarding a couple, but there are plenty of people selling on the exchanges. There is no liquidity shortage that I can see.
- mrb 13y agoAh, the old and false "holding" argument. 2 million coins have changed hands in the last 30 days: http://bitcoinity.org/markets/list?currency=ALL&span=30d http://bitcoinity.org/markets/list?currency=ALL&span=30d And that is just on these exchanges, not even counting other places of exchanges (coinbase which is probably the 2nd largest coins seller in the US), or purchases (Bitpay signed up 10 thousand vendors!), etc. If this rate is kept, the entire existent volume of bitcoins, a bit less than 12 million, would change hands in the next 6 months. It doesn't matter if it is 1 coin changing hands 12 million times, or 12 million coins changing hands one time each. Volume is volume. And it proves that not that many coins are being hoarded.
- jaggederest 13y ago> It doesn't matter if it is 1 coin changing hands 12 million times, or 12 million coins changing hands one time each. Volume is volume. Correct > And it proves that not that many coins are being hoarded. False. There's nothing in what you said to give any logical or empirical evidence that coins aren't being hoarded. You'd be better off making the argument that it doesn't matter that they're being hoarded because the market is still liquid.
- mrb 13y ago
- fleitz 13y ago> And yet Bitcoin value continue to raise. If history repeats itself, we should see 1 Bitcoin levels at around $2,000. It's 2007 I have a house I bought for $300,000 which is now worth $600,000, would you like to buy my house and in two years you will make another $600,000? If there's one thing about real estate in the last 10 years it's that it's proven all those naysayers like Shiller wrong.
- tslathrow 13y agoI'm not sure we've waiting long enough for Shiller to be proved correct. If monetary policy wasn't blowing the roof out on equity valuations, we'd be seeing mean-reversion as we should.
- saym 13y agoCan you elaborate on his prediction?
- tslathrow 13y agoI would suggest you read up a bit on Robert Shiller and CAPE
- fiatjaf 13y agoThanks for the elaboration and useful links.
- tslathrow 13y agoI assumed you could just look in any introductory finance textbook, but here: CAPE Formula: - Adjust each of the yearly earnings of the last 10 years for inflation. - Average the result of the step 1. - Divide the current price by the result of step 2. When I say yearly earnings I really mean trailing twelve months. Use TIPS etc to adjust for inflation. CAPE is mostly horseshit but basically it's designed to give a sense of over/undervaluation of risky assets It's about as awful as any other valuation metric though.
- Lambdanaut 13y ago"Asics? There will be a flood of new coins." Whoever made that argument has a fundamental misunderstanding of the pre-defined rate of Bitcoin production.
- pseudonym 13y agoIt's hard to source an argument when you're quoting strawmen.