6 ms·
Fuck it, let's just argue the other way and save some time. What evidence is there that we should ignore the well-known design principles of encapsulation and
by angersock 13y ago
Fuck it, let's just argue the other way and save some time.
What evidence is there that we should ignore the well-known design principles of encapsulation and separation-of-concerns and thus allow the TSA to access data held by other agencies?
- jamesaguilar 13y agoThose are programming design principles, not security principles nor natural laws. It does not do to assume that principles in one domain carry over to other domains.
- angersock 13y agoThey are system-design principles, and one can consider that the TSA folks are Turing Complete, therefore the laws apply. Q.E.D. Don't assume that they don't carry.
- jamesaguilar 13y agoSo, since the body is also likely turing complete via DNA, can I assume that DRY applies and preemptively remove one of your lungs? Give me a break.
- mdc 13y agoDo you really believe that DRY in coding precludes redundancy in implementation?
- jamesaguilar 13y agoIt tends to forbid code duplication, which is what the lungs are. Redundant implementations are two implementations which work a different way, which no, are not forbidden by DRY.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> It tends to forbid code duplication, which is what the lungs are. Lungs are not code duplication any more than running two instances of an application to provide greater peak performance or hot-standby is code duplication. You are confusing duplication of elements of the real system with duplication of specification (programming is executable specification, not the real system.)
- jamesaguilar 13y agoI concede this point.
- angersock 13y agoLungs are more like load balancers, right? You should've suggested (in the DRY sense) removing extra copies of sequences in DNA--excepting, you know, that I don't think that we know that is safe (those may be there for redundancy as well). Perhaps you work somewhere where the concept of redundancy is important? Stop being obtuse; you clearly seem to see the point I was getting at.
- jamesaguilar 13y agoI certainly see the argument you were trying to make. I also think the way you tried to make it is totally invalid and casts no light on whether the TSA should or shouldn't use the processes they are planning to adopt.
- angersock 13y agoWhy is the TSA magically exempt from sound systems-engineering concepts? You never explained that.
- jamesaguilar 13y agoPrinciple zero is that the system should correctly perform the work required by its owners. If what you're saying is that an additional system should be injected that has access to all the required information, and the TSA should query that system, then I won't argue. That would be a balancing act of coordination costs versus the cost of the technical debt added to the TSA, but I don't feel I have sufficient insight to analyze that balance where I currently am. Likewise if you are arguing any other rearrangement of information owners such that some process can access information and inform the TSA's decisions. If what you're saying is that the TSA should not perform some work because it's not simple to do that work in accordance with other system design principles, then I fear you have fundamentally misunderstood what those principles are for. I withdraw my claim that the TSA should not seek to optimize according to design principles. I still believe that you are applying them too broadly, but it isn't a position I care to defend at the moment.
- dragonwriter 13y agoEven if that was a valid application of DRY, no, it wouldn't, because you aren't the system owner, and nothing justifies anyone other than the system owner making changes to the system to achieve fidelity to any principle of system design.
- dragonwriter 13y agoLike many "programming design principles", they are in fact principles for the design of robust systems that are amenable to (1) reasoning about, and (2) adapting to changing circumstances, and are not at all special to the domain of programming.
- EGreg 13y agoEncapsulation and separation of concerns does not mean that data is inaccessible to requesters when it is needed. It just means it's accessed through the proper interfaces and the right clearances are given. If the TSA has MORE information then there will be LESS hassle and MORE accuracy. That, multiplied by the number of people currently affected and delayed by the security checks should also improve the experience by quite a lot.
- angersock 13y agoIf the TSA has MORE information then there will be LESS hassle and MORE accuracy. So, what is their current accuracy? We already know that no TSA --> no hassle. Yours is at least a testable hypothesis.
- dhimes 13y agoThat's the way it was before 911; before the Department of Homeland Security. After 911, there was a clusterfuck of confusion about who knew what because Customs didn't want to talk to the TSA who didn't want to talk to the Secret Service who didn't want to talk to.... Or that was what we were told. In part to alleviate this symptom, the responsibilities for 22 departments were thrown together under the DHS. So, at least the administration running things at the time thought they saw evidence that it was needed.
- angersock 13y agoSo, there's no evidence, is what you're telling me, other than the presumed wisdom of those bozos.
- dhimes 13y agoThat is indeed what I was saying- save for the fact there might be some evidence that requires special privilege to access, or might exist in the observations of some of those who were involved.
- jessaustin 13y ago...at least the administration running things at the time thought... IIRC, Bush2 was initially against the formation of the DHS. After a week of everyone in Congress asking why he didn't care about teh Children, and also why was he so against spending in their districts, he caved. Incidentally, I don't assume that Bush2 was against DHS because of the sound organizational principle that the best way to make a group of poorly performing orgs worse is to pack them all together under an additional management layer. He might well not have cared at all, so he could use the opportunity to extract concessions from other politicians.