5 ms·
I am not worried about it. People care about security and don't welcome the hassle. For the privacy advocates when it comes to public transportation like flying
by EGreg 13y ago
I am not worried about it. People care about security and don't welcome the hassle. For the privacy advocates when it comes to public transportation like flying: what do you fear may happen as a result of greater background checks?
This article reminded me of this one from 3 years ago: http://www.outsidethebeltway.com/why_israeli_airport_security_wont_work_in_usa/ http://www.outsidethebeltway.com/why_israeli_airport_securit...
(PS: I predict this comment will be heavily voted down just because people disagree with me, and I want to see whether HN users on aggregate punish opposing views or reward a willingness to reasonably discuss something.)
However, the below doesn't make much sense together:
"The prescreening, some of which is already taking place, is described in documents the T.S.A. released to comply with government regulations about the collection and use of individuals’ data, but the details of the program have not been publicly announced.
It is unclear precisely what information the agency is relying upon to make these risk assessments."
So what is the regulation about disclosing collection of info, if it's still unclear after disclosure what information they are using?
- angersock 13y agoFuck it, let's just argue the other way and save some time. What evidence is there that we should ignore the well-known design principles of encapsulation and separation-of-concerns and thus allow the TSA to access data held by other agencies?
- jamesaguilar 13y agoThose are programming design principles, not security principles nor natural laws. It does not do to assume that principles in one domain carry over to other domains.
- angersock 13y agoThey are system-design principles, and one can consider that the TSA folks are Turing Complete, therefore the laws apply. Q.E.D. Don't assume that they don't carry.
- jamesaguilar 13y agoSo, since the body is also likely turing complete via DNA, can I assume that DRY applies and preemptively remove one of your lungs? Give me a break.
- mdc 13y agoDo you really believe that DRY in coding precludes redundancy in implementation?
- jamesaguilar 13y agoIt tends to forbid code duplication, which is what the lungs are. Redundant implementations are two implementations which work a different way, which no, are not forbidden by DRY.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> It tends to forbid code duplication, which is what the lungs are. Lungs are not code duplication any more than running two instances of an application to provide greater peak performance or hot-standby is code duplication. You are confusing duplication of elements of the real system with duplication of specification (programming is executable specification, not the real system.)
- jamesaguilar 13y agoI concede this point.
- angersock 13y agoLungs are more like load balancers, right? You should've suggested (in the DRY sense) removing extra copies of sequences in DNA--excepting, you know, that I don't think that we know that is safe (those may be there for redundancy as well). Perhaps you work somewhere where the concept of redundancy is important? Stop being obtuse; you clearly seem to see the point I was getting at.
- dragonwriter 13y agoLike many "programming design principles", they are in fact principles for the design of robust systems that are amenable to (1) reasoning about, and (2) adapting to changing circumstances, and are not at all special to the domain of programming.
- EGreg 13y agoEncapsulation and separation of concerns does not mean that data is inaccessible to requesters when it is needed. It just means it's accessed through the proper interfaces and the right clearances are given. If the TSA has MORE information then there will be LESS hassle and MORE accuracy. That, multiplied by the number of people currently affected and delayed by the security checks should also improve the experience by quite a lot.
- angersock 13y agoIf the TSA has MORE information then there will be LESS hassle and MORE accuracy. So, what is their current accuracy? We already know that no TSA --> no hassle. Yours is at least a testable hypothesis.
- dhimes 13y agoThat's the way it was before 911; before the Department of Homeland Security. After 911, there was a clusterfuck of confusion about who knew what because Customs didn't want to talk to the TSA who didn't want to talk to the Secret Service who didn't want to talk to.... Or that was what we were told. In part to alleviate this symptom, the responsibilities for 22 departments were thrown together under the DHS. So, at least the administration running things at the time thought they saw evidence that it was needed.
- angersock 13y agoSo, there's no evidence, is what you're telling me, other than the presumed wisdom of those bozos.
- dhimes 13y agoThat is indeed what I was saying- save for the fact there might be some evidence that requires special privilege to access, or might exist in the observations of some of those who were involved.
- jessaustin 13y ago...at least the administration running things at the time thought... IIRC, Bush2 was initially against the formation of the DHS. After a week of everyone in Congress asking why he didn't care about teh Children, and also why was he so against spending in their districts, he caved. Incidentally, I don't assume that Bush2 was against DHS because of the sound organizational principle that the best way to make a group of poorly performing orgs worse is to pack them all together under an additional management layer. He might well not have cared at all, so he could use the opportunity to extract concessions from other politicians.
- drcube 13y ago> For the privacy advocates when it comes to public transportation like flying: what do you fear may happen as a result of greater background checks? False positives, increased harassment/inconveniece of innocent people, chilling effects, driving people away from airlines towards other, less efficient means of long distance travel, even as airlines are struggling to stay in business. TSA becoming more powerful, free citizens becoming desensitized to privacy invasions, increased rape-scans, crotch fondling, etc. Generally, it makes our country a worse place to travel to/from/within. And what are the benefits, again? Because I'm not seeing any, and that is the question you should be asking, not simply "what's the harm?".
- EGreg 13y agoI would argue that there are MORE false positives when you don't have enough information. After all, mathematically speaking let's say you sample X things versus X + Y things. Assuming there to be a similar probability distribution for the decision making (same first moments at least), a greater sample size would lead to greater accuracy and therefore less false positives, as well as less false negatives.
- hdevalence 13y agoYou should consider applying Bayes' rule here. For reference, there are 800 million airline passengers in the US every year. Good luck.
- EGreg 13y ago?
- minor_nitwit 13y agoEx. You have a test that detects cancer with 99% certainty, and a prevalence of cancer of 1 in 1 million people. In a sample size of 100 million people: People with cancer correctly identified: 99%*100=99 people People with cancer not identified: 1%*100=1 person People without cancer falsely identified= 1%*99,999,900 = 999,999 people People without cancer correctly identified:99%*99,999,900=98,999,901 people Even with 99% accuracy you have nearly a million people falsely identified, but only identify 99 people with cancer. Now extend this to terrorism, 800 million riders for 12 years, and a prevalence of 2? possible terrorists (shoe, underwear) in the last 12 years. Also keep in mind that since both of these guys made it on the plane, the accuracy of the the terrorist screening process may not be too high.
- jnbiche 13y agoI downvoted you. Frankly, I would have upvoted you if not for your ridiculous meta comment about HN, including: "I predict this comment will be heavily voted down just because people disagree with me [...]". I suspect that your comments about what HN is or isn't likely to do in response to your comment is why you're being downvoted, not because of your rational (if wrongheaded) discussion. I rarely engage in meta debates, and it's possible you're just trolling, but I just wanted you to know.
- blisterpeanuts 13y agoPolitically tinged comments seem to get downvoted quite a bit here, similarly to Slashdot and many other forums. I've experienced this myself. In my opinion, downvoting a comment for any reason other than flagrant trolling, personal attacks, or similar content that degrades the dialogue should be considered inappropriate use of the privilege, because it undermines the feature and renders it pointless. On a Slashdot political topic, I have to read at -1 to catch all the points of view.
- jnbiche 13y agoTo be clear, my downvote was very much in the spirit of two of HN's guidelines: Resist complaining about being downmodded. It never does any good, and it makes boring reading. Please don't bait other users by inviting them to downmod you. See: http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html I didn't downvote your comment, but you're pretty clearly flouting the first guideline. If you want to be a productive part of a community, please respect the guidelines of that community. I have no problem with contrarian political remarks, as long as they're presented rationally and refrain from breaking the community's guidelines.
- EGreg 13y agoI appreciate that feedback, but I actually added that "prediction" after the value on the comment reached -2. So I am pretty sure it was because people disagreed with my stance, as I had provided a bunch of thoughtful reasoning besides simply stating my opinion and the comment was inviting reasonable discussion. So I decided to call out this phenomenon and make this a genuine test of whether I would be downvoted simply because people disagreed with my position, WITHOUT discussing it first. But sadly it was contaminated by people like you downvoting because I had violated a guideline. I guess in retrospect it wasn't that productive to do it.
- mindcrime 13y agoPeople care about security The TSA doesn't do anything to make us more secure. They might (maybe) make you marginally more secure on the airplane, but if you stop and think about it... a terrorist doesn't need to blow up an airplane to cause terror. All they need is a large number of people compacted into a fairly small space, where their destructive devices can cause large numbers of injuries or deaths. Like, for example... ... ... ... ... in line in front of the TSA security checkpoint. Yep, by adding another chokepoint / bottleneck, the TSA have created a new target. They haven't done anything to solve the problem, they've only moved it.
- DanBC 13y agoYou're not allowed to take stuff through that checkpoint because it might be an explosive, so they take the stuff off you, and put it in a big bin, next to the line of people.
- bediger4000 13y agoYeah, I had an airport cop at Denver International tell me I couldn't park my family's minivan for 2 minutes in a loading zone while my wife came down the escalator from a floor up. The minivan might be full of explosives, and I might blow the arrivals pick-up zone up while parked. Why wouldn't I try to blow it up while cruising past in the stop-n-go stream of traffic whose drivers are looking for their person? If this is the rubbish the TSA tells their trench-level grunts, then what kind of otherworldly nonsense circulates at higher levels in that "organization"?
- mikeash 13y ago"For the privacy advocates when it comes to public transportation like flying: what do you fear may happen as a result of greater background checks?" I fear that some mistake, perhaps just data corruption in some gigantic database somewhere, will affect my government file and permanently ruin my life.