6 ms·
Security Check Now Starts Long Before You Fly
- auctiontheory 13y agoSo many cold-war era US criticisms of the Soviet bloc are coming true in this country, except that the surveillance here is more effective than what we saw in The Lives of Others.
- MrZongle2 13y ago"Papers, please" has been replaced with "Wait while we review our database containing your personal information". This is the road to a police state.
- fijal 13y agoThat does not make the "papers please" part disappear btw. Last time I checked, the queues were long anyway.
- jessaustin 13y ago"Papers please" will disappear as they gradually roll out the bar code tattoos. Starting next year.
- EGreg 13y agoI am not worried about it. People care about security and don't welcome the hassle. For the privacy advocates when it comes to public transportation like flying: what do you fear may happen as a result of greater background checks? This article reminded me of this one from 3 years ago: http://www.outsidethebeltway.com/why_israeli_airport_security_wont_work_in_usa/ http://www.outsidethebeltway.com/why_israeli_airport_securit... (PS: I predict this comment will be heavily voted down just because people disagree with me, and I want to see whether HN users on aggregate punish opposing views or reward a willingness to reasonably discuss something.) However, the below doesn't make much sense together: "The prescreening, some of which is already taking place, is described in documents the T.S.A. released to comply with government regulations about the collection and use of individuals’ data, but the details of the program have not been publicly announced. It is unclear precisely what information the agency is relying upon to make these risk assessments." So what is the regulation about disclosing collection of info, if it's still unclear after disclosure what information they are using?
- angersock 13y agoFuck it, let's just argue the other way and save some time. What evidence is there that we should ignore the well-known design principles of encapsulation and separation-of-concerns and thus allow the TSA to access data held by other agencies?
- jamesaguilar 13y agoThose are programming design principles, not security principles nor natural laws. It does not do to assume that principles in one domain carry over to other domains.
- angersock 13y agoThey are system-design principles, and one can consider that the TSA folks are Turing Complete, therefore the laws apply. Q.E.D. Don't assume that they don't carry.
- jamesaguilar 13y agoSo, since the body is also likely turing complete via DNA, can I assume that DRY applies and preemptively remove one of your lungs? Give me a break.
- mdc 13y agoDo you really believe that DRY in coding precludes redundancy in implementation?
- jamesaguilar 13y agoIt tends to forbid code duplication, which is what the lungs are. Redundant implementations are two implementations which work a different way, which no, are not forbidden by DRY.
- ape4 13y agoOf course, when they scan your passport (drivers license) into their computer at the security desk they are looking you up. That data was gathered before you arrived at the airport.
- jevinskie 13y ago> For instance, an update about the T.S.A.’s Transportation Security Enforcement Record System, which contains information about travelers accused of “violations or potential violations” of security regulations, warns that the records may be shared with “a debt collection agency for the purpose of debt collection.” This is absurd. So now the government is snitching on citizens who are traveling domestically.
- malandrew 13y agoWait, WTF does airport security have to do with debt collection?
- dmix 13y agoWhat does 99.99-% of phone call records have to do with Terrorism/National Security? Mass data collection doesn't discriminate. These organizations are in the business of collecting everything about you. "Debt collection" is just their primary business. For ex, most American pharmacies sell what prescriptions people are buying [1] to data mining companies. But they at least "de-identify", due to federal regulations. TSA operates outside quite a few laws/regulations protecting individual rights. We can now add information privacy to that list. http://www.kevinmd.com/blog/2011/06/pharmacies-selling-prescription-information-data-mining-companies.html http://www.kevinmd.com/blog/2011/06/pharmacies-selling-presc...
- atlanticus 13y agoIs that through credit card data? And how does that not violate HIPPA?
- weland 13y agoWell, who knows if someone's gonna be so pissed off at tax collectors that he's gonna blow a fucking plane out of the sky. I mean, really pissed off. Sorry, I couldn't find anything better :(. I've taken the Devil's case pro bono, he's probably gonna fire my ass.
- gohrt 13y agoThe patriot thing to do is to opt in to all the physically invasive screenings and opt out of all the data collection. The more time spent on searching you at the airport, the more everyone else is delayed (shared sacrifice) and the more visible these security theatrics are.
- EGreg 13y agoWhat baffles me is how come the subway system has never seen major terrorist attacks despite having very low security and carrying millions of New Yorkers (or citizens of other cities) a day. I am very thankful for this, but wondering why. If someone wanted to cause a massive amount of damage it would not be difficult to do.
- lazyant 13y agoer.. London?
- AlisdairSH 13y agoand Tokyo?
- vividmind 13y agoMoscow probably had a couple if I can recall...
- PilateDeGuerre 13y agoPerhaps terrorism isn't quite the threat to us that the US state makes it out to be.
- frank_boyd 13y agoIt increasingly looks like the "ruling 1%" are preparing for social unrest, respectively for the protection of their power and wealth which will be questioned.
- malandrew 13y agoThis is the feeling I increasingly get with all this. If this turns out to be the case, I can only imagine that this works for a while until those doing the enforcing realize that they have more in common with the 99% and then turn on the 1%.
- frank_boyd 13y agoPolice State v1.0
- angersock 13y agoPlease don't make this sort of comment without more useful things to say.
- JonSkeptic 13y ago>The T.S.A. has emphasized its goal of giving 25 percent of all passengers lighter screening by the end of next year, meaning they can keep their shoes and jackets on, wait in separate lines and leave laptop computers in their bags. But travelers who find themselves in the higher-risk category can be subjected to repeated searches. So if we are good Citizens, we will be rewarded. Only bad Citizens have something to hide and they will be molested for it. Somehow this does not comfort me at all.
- fibbery 13y agobad citizens and brown people...
- malandrew 13y agoWorse yet, I was under the impression that only citizens that have been arrested and fingerprinted had their fingerprints on file. Now with this, they are creating a reason to get a completely law-abiding citizen's fingerprint on file. We've been successful in avoiding a national ID system, but it looks like one is now being implemented via the TSA under the guise of a "convenience program" that you are coerced into participating in by increasingly making your live a living hell if you don't. It would be valuable to bring something like this to the attention of the NRA, because they are one of the few groups that does a lot of work to prevent a national ID program and centralized databases of biometric markers.
- thex86 13y agoQuestion for the Americans: what is still keeping the TSA in business, even in spite of all these draconian practices? Why can't someone fight the TSA in SCOTUS? Things like this make me really glad to be living in Canada. At least there is some - if not a lot - expectation of privacy and protection against unreasonable search and seizure.
- refurb 13y agoWhat makes you think Canada isn't working hand-in-hand with the TSA? As we've seen over the past couple of months, the only difference between the US and rest of Europe is that the US intelligence system is on the front page of the news right now. Everyone else is doing similar stuff, just not in the spotlight.
- contextual 13y agoThe US government is racist. It's as simple as that. And their fixation with people who look of Arab descent is only going to get worse as citizens shrug their shoulders in resignation and accept that too[1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shifting_baseline https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shifting_baseline
- znowi 13y ago> Privacy groups contacted by The New York Times expressed concern over the security agency’s widening reach At this rate of government's lust for control and power, it is time to express outrage already. I'll enjoy watching when they introduce random body cavity search at the airports. By that time, people will be conditioned enough to comply. After all, it's for our own protection.
- jessaustin 13y agoI'll enjoy watching... Rule 34?