3 ms·
Before everyone goes on about American healthcare and obesity, consider what the numbers are actually measuring. As far as I can tell from the article, these l
by humanrebar 13y ago
Before everyone goes on about American healthcare and obesity, consider what the numbers are actually measuring.
As far as I can tell from the article, these life expectancy numbers do not compensate for suicide, homicide, premature births (some countries don't count them as births), and accidental death (as in car accidents).
I would like to see more of the same charts, but instead of just graphing life expectancy at birth, graph life expectancy from ages 1, 11, 21, 31, 41, and so on. I would compare the "Life Expectancy from Age X" graph for the U.S. against the same graphs for other countries. Then I would look at leading causes of death for each age group in the U.S. Then I would have a much more quantifiable idea of why citizens in other countries tend to live longer than U.S. citizens.
Here's an interesting podcasts where a couple of economists discuss this kind of metric as a measure of longevity and health: http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2012/07/scott_atlas_on.html http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2012/07/scott_atlas_on.html
EDIT: This is important because counting thousands of premature births and having a much higher rate of death due to accidents and violence will really wreck the U.S. average. In that case, talking about how Americans eat too much red meat is mostly beside the point.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> I would like to see more of the same charts, but instead of just graphing life expectancy at birth, graph life expectancy from ages 1, 11, 21, 31, 41, and so on. I would compare the "Life Expectancy from Age X" graph for the U.S. against the same graphs for other countries. The article itself notes: In 2011, the National Institutes of Health issued a report that tried to make sense of it all. Right away, they found our weak spot. "U.S. women have relatively high mortality rates at the younger older ages," they said, which means when women hit their 55th birthdays, for the next almost 20 years, roughly 55 to 75, they will die more often than women in comparable countries. Americans get more lung disease, more heart disease, more diabetes. If Americans reach 75, they get competitive again, but that early old age is where we lose ground. American men showed pretty much the same weakness at roughly the same times. And the NIH study [1] linked in the article actually has the kind of charts that you suggest should be done comparing life expectancy at various ages. It would maybe help if instead of reciting canned arguments based assumptions generated by the title, people would actually read the linked articles. [1] http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK62373/ http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK62373/
- humanrebar 13y agoMy comment was to push back at already-posted assumptions about the U.S. healthcare system in general and obesity in particular. I have gone through the original study, but the NPR article said: "The NIH report says that in 2002, 2003 and 2004, life expectancy in France increased by 10 months, which is a crazy pace (and I'm guessing it hasn't stayed that way)." The likeliest explanation for a jump that large is a change in methodology, but there could be other factors (climate? there was a big heat wave in 2003). The U.S. does have a different culture and climate than these other countries. I'm very happy to read an article that discusses the complexity of comparing life expectancies between countries, but the NPR article wasn't it and the HN comment section is just now getting to the point where people are discussing what the numbers really mean. The podcast I linked is more along those lines as well, but it also goes into other popular measurements of national health as well, if I recall correctly.
- PeterisP 13y agoIf you're doing longevity studies in Europe, then you should get huge differences between cohorts separated by a few years due to WW2 - there are significant long-term effects (such as changes in metabolism gene expression) caused by, say, near-starvation during pregnancy or infanthood; and current longevity studies all include people who were essentially born on a battlefield as well as those who weren't due to small differences of age or location.