4 ms·
Costs will rise to the minimum that everyone is known to afford (or higher to deny the minimum income). How do you support such a claim? If I was a business an
by chongli 13y ago
Costs will rise to the minimum that everyone is known to afford (or higher to deny the minimum income).
How do you support such a claim? If I was a business and all my competitors did this, I would undercut them and make a killing!
Basic income (or something similar) is an inevitable outcome of our development as a civilization. As technology continues to drive up productivity, the demand for labour falls. As the demand for labour falls, so does employment and consequently the demand for goods and services fall as well.
It may be a very rough transition to get there but eventually we will have a society where robots make everything we need and we are forced to devise a system for allocating these products to the people.
- return0 13y agoAnecdotally, we have witnessed prices of products soaring in southern europe after the introduction of the euro and real estate bubbles due to cheap loans. Prices are adjusting back due to cuts now, only the profit margins are reduced. Similarly to how cartels work, free money just creates inflation.
- Aloisius 13y agoIf everyone around you tripled their prices, you would make a killing, but then you'd quickly run out of product, have massive lines and frustrated customers. At some point you might even realize that if you raise your prices 2.5x, you'd probably make more money while still undercutting the competition. But you'd still have raised your prices.
- ck2 13y agoReally? Is that how things like healthcare costs in the USA work out? Competition solves all? Because we have unlimited hospitals and doctors and yet a Tylenol in the hospital is hundreds of dollars (Obamacare won't fix that either because now more people can pay hundreds). Internet, Cable, Cellphone service, all seem to rise to the most people can afford. Rent on apartment complexes near each other owned by different management companies magically stay within a several percent of each other. If you gave everyone $1000 a month, rent will magically rise to at least half that for even the smallest efficiency.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- brianlweiner 13y agoWe actually don't have unlimited hospitals or doctors. New hospital constructions will often require a 'Certificate of Need' - existing hospitals can essentially veto any expansions. We haven't expanded our medical school supplies in 30 years either. We essentially graduate the same # of doctors as we did in 1980, although demand for medical services has increased significantly over that period. https://www.aamc.org/download/153708/data/charts1982to2012.pdf https://www.aamc.org/download/153708/data/charts1982to2012.p...
- ck2 13y agoThere are nearly 6000 hospitals in the USA with nearly a million beds. That's a MASSIVE amount of overlapping resources. Yet every cost in a hospital, even to get to one via ambulance, is breath-taking. There are countries with far fewer resources (ie. Canada) with far lower costs.
- danieldk 13y agoIf you gave everyone $1000 a month, rent will magically rise to at least half that for even the smallest efficiency. You do realize that there is a minimum wage in The Netherlands (Euro 1469 per month gross) and welfare (e.g. for a married couple Euro 1323, single up to Euro 926 per month)? So, that should've happened already. Besides that, we have a system for social housing, which everyone with a low income can use, which is regulated. E.g. when I was still a PhD candidate, I made a bit over 2000 Euro (gross) per month, but could rent a house with three bedrooms for 390 Euro. The price is determined based on size, facilities, etc. I like the idea of a basic income, since it would kill a lot of bureaucracy that checks that people who are able to work actively solicit positions, etc. It'd be nice if the CPB (the organization that is responsible for making guestimations of economic effects) could work it through.
- ck2 13y agoSounds like you already have cost control in place. In which case basic income guarantees could work. In the USA it would become a predatory market to squeeze money from.
- ry0ohki 13y agoBecause you are setting a floor. First, if you make a minimum income of 1,000, anyone making less or around that will demand a raise, after all why would I work if I could get the same amount loafing around the house. So the mid-lower tiers get a raise, and now the tier above that doesn't want to make the same as the lower tier and they get a raise, so there is inflation as everyone suddenly as a lot more money to spend. Which feels great for maybe a month or maybe a day, but with everyone making more money, goods in that area will rise in price, as landlords find they can make more money etc... and then we're back in the same situation. In theory goods outside of this economy with a floor would remain the same, but since the people that need to import it, store it, etc... would also be affected by the inflation in the end it doesn't net anything. TLDR; a basic income is an illusion, and inflation would quickly catch up.
- phaemon 13y ago>First, if you make a minimum income of 1,000, anyone making less or around that will demand a raise, after all why would I work if I could get the same amount loafing around the house. You've misunderstood the concept. Everybody gets this. If you're currently making 900 a month, then you now make 1900 a month. You go to work because you want more than the basic 1000.
- efdee 13y agoYou are confusing "minimum income" and "basic income". "Basic income" is something everyone gets, employed or unemployed. Whatever you make in salary comes on top of that. So there is no "why would I work if I could get the same amount loafing around the house".
- parasight 13y agoOk, then why not adjust the basic income by the percentage of inflation on a regular basis? I mean we can cope with inflation without basic income. Why not with basic income?
- arobbins 13y agoI don't think anyone can make less than 1,000 if that is the basic income. Everyone gets 1,000 plus whatever they earn from a job. If someone's job previously paid 500, then their new income is 1,500.
- lostInTheWoods3 13y agoGiving out "free" money is the equivalent of the government printing money. You don't have to be an economics major to realize that printing money (or dropping it out of an airplane) cheapens the value of that money. Hence, you end up with higher prices (inflation).
- thebooktocome 13y agoExcept the Dutch basic income proposal doesn't give out "free" money; it gives out money the government has already collected in the form of taxes.
- bhauer 13y agoExactly, and most basic income proposals would cut other social safety net systems in like amounts. So the net outlay by the government (in money it doesn't actually create; it just confiscates or prints) is the same. The latter gives the recipient the freedom to choose how to use their basic income, giving them incentive to select fair trades rather than just consuming all of the free stuff regardless of actual cost. This actually drives prices downward. However, it does remove the political power of the central planning committees. And that is concerning to some.
- loceng 13y agoOne factor, unless you owned the building your rent would go up until they took all your profits - or shut you down for not agreeing to their price increase when it comes contract renewal time.