10 ms·
Sales Are Colossal, Shares Are Soaring. All Amazon Is Missing Is a Profit
- pinaceae 13y agosales is kind of easy if you don't care about profit. also kills off competition, which in turn makes sales easier. but what happens once profits are needed? or is amazon the largest NPO on earth?
- frank_boyd 13y agoCorrect. 1. Give away profit, to increase market share 2. Repeat 3. Enjoy your new monopoly 4. With competition gone and customers additionally locked in via your technology platform: Set your prices as you wish
- _red 13y ago5. Watch competitors instantly spring up. *Note: there is no such thing as a non-government enforced monopoly. Marketshare != Monopoly
- Ygg2 13y agoTrue, but what if for some reason government considers Amazon too big to fail. It's not that far fetched.
- GFischer 13y agoThere's no such thing as a country without government, unless Amazon sets up on (and only sells to) Somalia or Eritrea :P
- njs12345 13y agoThat's a fairly contentious assertion to make and not one that is universally held by mainstream economists by any means.
- lemma 13y agoTo back you up: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_monopoly http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_monopoly
- beagle3 13y agoCounterexamples: Microsoft (desktop OS), standard oil.
- brianlweiner 13y agoIt's not such a slam dunk case. "Some economic historians have observed that Standard Oil was in the process of losing its monopoly at the time of its breakup in 1911. Although Standard had 90 percent of American refining capacity in 1880, by 1911 that had shrunk to between 60 and 65 percent, due to the expansion in capacity by competitors.[41] Numerous regional competitors (such as Pure Oil in the East, Texaco and Gulf Oil in the Gulf Coast, Cities Service and Sun in the Midcontinent, Union in California, and Shell overseas) had organized themselves into competitive vertically integrated oil companies, the industry structure pioneered years earlier by Standard itself. In addition, demand for petroleum products was increasing more rapidly than the ability of Standard to expand. The result was that although in 1911 Standard still controlled most production in the older US regions of the Appalachian Basin (78 percent share, down from 92 percent in 1880), Lima-Indiana (90 percent, down from 95 percent in 1906), and the Illinois Basin (83 percent, down from 100 percent in 1906), its share was much lower in the rapidly expanding new regions that would dominate US oil production in the 20th century. In 1911 Standard controlled only 44 percent of production in the Midcontinent, 29 percent in California, and 10 percent on the Gulf Coast.[42]" http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Standard_Oil#Monopoly_charges_and_anti-trust_legislation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Standard_Oil#Monopoly_charges_a... There's also no great evidence that Standard Oil raised prices once they had established such large market share. http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/graph/?id=M04182US000NYM264NNBR http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/graph/?id=M04182US000NY...
- beagle3 13y agoI don't have time to research the numbers right now, but from your quote it sounds like 1870 to 1900 it did enjoy some 80% control. That's long enough to be considered a monopoly for most purposes.
- icebraining 13y agoMicrosoft has a government-enforced monopoly (copyright and patents).
- jbooth 13y agoI agree that in Amazon's business it's hard or impossible to establish monopoly pricing practices. That does not mean there's no such thing as a non-government enforced monopoly. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_monopoly http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_monopoly
- mattlutze 13y agoMy history knowledge is shaky, but I don't recall Standard Oil being "government enforced".
- _red 13y agoYour historical knowledge is ok. But it wasn't a monopoly. At its peak it had 90% market-share. It was never "illegal" or "impossible" to sell petroleum in competition to it -- just highly very difficult to compete with them. In the same vein, google has 9-1 share of the internet search market....should we call it a "monopoly"?
- jbooth 13y agoTotally different. Google has mindshare and a seemingly-insurmountable lead, but they do not have a monopoly on internet search results. I could put up the worlds crappiest search engine next weekend and theoretically be 'competing' with them. Spider a few million websites and link to them in some order and you're in the same business. Standard Oil, at its peak, had an actual near-monopoly on most discovered sources of oil. You can't even get into the oil business unless you discover more oil -- in theory, they could have used their resources to stay on top of each oil source as it was discovered. No amount of old-fashioned ingenuity can compete with that.
- mabhatter 13y agoI get so sick of this. Monopoly economics is based on statistics of a random buyer wanting to buy stuff from a random seller. With NO INTERFERENCE. Statistitions consider 25% chance to be "unlikely", and 75% chance to be "very likely". So a 90% chance of doing business with ONE company is as Statistically close to 100% that it might as well BE 100% for economic purposes. Once a company hits 75% or so they have no "economic need" to write restrictive exclusive contracts as they basically control the market. Remember, the RULES OF FREE MARKETS assume there are ALWAYS enough buyers and sellers that NEITHER side has a group large enough to independently affect the market prices. As soon as a buyer or seller hits about 25% they aren't following the rules of the "Free Market system" they are Capitalists attempting to REMOVE the RIGHTS of the Free Market system from others using aggregation of capital resources.
- iMark 13y agoAmazon have been steadily building their infrastructure and supply chain for years, things that aren't easily built from scratch.
- josephlord 13y agoIn the general cases there can be non-government controlled monopolies. In this particular case of online retail and "cloud" services the barriers to entry are quite low so your conclusion may be right although exposure is tricky for online retailing if everyone just searches Amazon.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- hershel 13y agoSince amazon invests all it's got in expansions and new offerings, It's really hard to talk about how much profit they make. And it's part of their advantage to keep this secret.
- jacques_chester 13y agoIt's not a secret and it's easy to talk about. Investments is in their cashflow statement. Per their 2012 Annual Report, with units in millions of dollars: Purchases of property and equipment, including internal-use software and website development (3,785) Which also booked elsewhere under Investing Activities in their cashflow statement. And profit: Net income (loss) (39) Amazon's free cashflow with investment would be about 4 billion dollars on the 2012 figures. In fact after investment they still booked $395M of free cashflow. Anyone can read these figures. You, me, Amazon's competitors. The Annual Report doesn't give the raw numbers, it gives a detailed discussion of what the numbers mean, how they are evolving and so on. This kind of disclosure is required by law so that investors aren't punished by unhappy surprises. There are some good books around on reading these kinds of figures, I recommend Financial Intelligence: A Manager's Guide to Knowing What the Numbers Really Mean.
- pjc50 13y agoProfit is taxable, whereas share price rise incurs taxes that are easier to avoid.
- VLM 13y agoMore precisely stated, a company that issues dividends decides when I'll be paying income taxes, whereas a company that grows share value/price lets me decide when I'd like to pay the income tax. Or another way to put it is the company decides when I pay dividend tax and how much, which kinda sucks, but I decide when I pay long term cap gains tax, which is pretty cool.
- existencebox 13y agoI see two sides to this. First; the closing paragraph of the article, clearly intended to convince you amazon is out to get you once they've wiped out all the other competition. That's all fine and dandy, and isn't I don't think directly controverted by evidence; but in the same statement, I think it is far from affirmed. The second side, then, is what I see this all as evidence of. Disclaimer, I know fuck all about the subtleties of running large businesses, but when you step back and look at the what they're doing at a high level, expanding facilities, exploring new markets, new products, during what is as the article stated an investment boom time and where maintaining a certain level of revenue might be a "somewhat safe bet", it makes sense to me that you would use this time to make more bets. Risk becomes more acceptable when you're not living dollar to dollar; the box of nails anecdote, simple as it is, spoke buckets to me. (maybe I'm overreading.) At the risk of showing extreme naivete, I would LOVE to for once believe that a company is simply using all of its financial resources to continually try to provide optimal and novel services. Shipping goes up in price; that's how the market works when you add more services without anyone funding em, the cash has to come from somewhere. I guess my hope is that the shipping is only raising due to their trying to provide new services, and that there will still be sufficient competition that amazon hasn't killed off to prevent this from going out of hand; and that it was just as I said above, a way to fund growth and try to balance for changing economic times, and not a sign of the impinging amazon monopolypse. Oops, suddenly essay, and now I'm late for work...
- Spooky23 13y agoIt's not some grand conspiracy, but if you lack competitive pressure, all of the sudden price competitiveness and service become less important. I grew up in a rural area. When Wal-Mart came at first, it was amazing. Clean stores, low prices, excellent service. They managed to put Ames, Jamesway and a few other marginal discount chains out of business. The convenience of driving to Wal-Mart and buying anything is more convenient that the closer speciality retailer, and thathelped kill of the specialty small retailers (hardware stores, etc). They mortally wounded K-Mart. They did this with ruthless efficiency and great service. Now, Wal-Mart owns the rural market. Guess what? The lines are like DMV, the stores are filthy and poorly merchandised (in the grocery section, they don't even unpack boxes), and the prices are often not so good. I hope that Amazon doesn't go that way, but history suggests otherwise.
- onedev 13y agoI think Prime is amazing. It's driven me to purchase things that I otherwise normally wouldn't have; that says a lot because I'm not usually one to buy a lot of "stuff". It's incredibly convenient, I often buy stuff from mobile and it'll be on my doorstep in two days. It's literally magic and I love it. I can't even begin to comprehend the levels of logistical wizardry it takes to make all of that happen. I'm inclined to think Amazon knows exactly what they're doing here.
- InclinedPlane 13y agoWhere do you live? Just wait until you live in one of the few magical cities in the US where under the right circumstances you can order something on amazon and have it show up at your house the same day, for no extra charge.
- onedev 13y agoI don't live in one of those magical cities, but if that really was the case then....that's just freakin' awesome in every way. There would literally be no reason for me to set foot inside another brick&morter store ever again. Throw in Amazon Fresh, and I wouldn't even have to go to the grocery store! Oh man, the thought of that is just magical. I'd be a healthier person for it.
- dingaling 13y ago> I think Prime is amazing. It was until Amazon created the concept of 'Add-on Items', which they have retrospectively applied to thousands of items. These items cannot be bought on their own, even if you wanted to pay for shipping. Not even by Prime members.
- jonknee 13y agoIt's the equivalent of the stuff next to the checkout of a retailer--it doesn't make sense to ship a $1-5 item on its own. I made an Amazon order yesterday and noticed an add-on item in my cart that I had saved from a previous session, I kept it on the order ("added on" you could say) and now I'll get the nail clippers I had been meaning to purchase as well as what I had originally bought. Happy Prime customer here.
- toyg 13y agoI think this sort of analysis misses three important elements: 1. Control. Absolute control over a huge chunk of worldwide B2B and B2C transactions is extremely valuable per se, in political and commercial terms. It's power that can be leveraged in a number of ways which are not necessarily reflected in the balance sheet. Bezos just bought the most influential newspaper in US political circles; this guy knows a thing or two about setting the agenda. 2. There is corporate profit and personal profit. Amazon employees are themselves turning quite a bit of personal profit. Does that make Amazon a No-Profit ? That's debatable. As someone else mentioned, pure profit is easy to tax, while "operating expenses" and share dealing can be shuffled around. 3. Industrialism. Many XIX-century industrialists saw their companies as agents of change as well as sources of profits. Amazon is pushing the envelop in commercial infrastructure (fully-automated warehouses, software-enhanced packaging, customer-seller variable relationships, etc etc) as well as creating whole new markets (AWS). As long as they don't start bleeding money, they're running a self-sustained engine of change, which is an achievement in itself.
- chalst 13y ago> corporate profit and personal profit The Amazon's board have a fiduciary duty not to enrich themselves at the expense of their shareholders. Amazon certainly is not a non-profit.
- hackula1 13y agoIncentives tend trump all, especially in major grey territory like this.
- taybin 13y agoIt's not unheard of for a board to enrich themselves. I believe a lot of the salaries for boards and executives is nothing more than a looting of the company at the shareholders' and host country's expense.
- chalst 13y agoSalaries for the board is a special case, since it usually needs to be agreed by the shareholders at the AGM. This case isn't really covered by fiduciary duty, since it is not a case of the board acting as agents of the shareholders (it would be different if the pay committee actually falsified their report).
- bedhead 13y agoThis story line is so incredibly hackneyed. It's boring. You either believe that Amazon is a giant non-profit, some kind of cosmic joke that Bezos is playing on the world, or you believe that Amazon is one of the most unique and brilliant companies ever and that maaaaaaybe their true profitability shouldn't be judged by our ever-increasing myopic standards.
- smackfu 13y agoIt's way easier to run a company if investors aren't expecting a profit. They don't complain about how you spend your cash, or that your operating margins have ticked up or down a percent this quarter, or that you missed your profit number in the latest results. Setting that profit expectation is the tricky bit, so why would Amazon give it up now?
- IBM 13y agoThe stock is tremendously overvalued, no value investor would ever buy AMZN. The assumptions needed to justify its current price are absurd. The bull case of "they'll put their competitors out of business and then raise prices" is one of the most shallow analyses of a company I've heard and just highlights that person's lack of business insight. The quote from Horace Dediu is correct, AMZN isn't going to be able to raise margins without costing it revenue growth, they're stuck as a low-cost retailer or they risk their customers going elsewhere. EDIT: I anticipate people getting hung-up on "value investor" because clearly AMZN is a "growth" company! Growth is always a function in assessing value, and sophisticated value investors know this. The popular convention of labeling something 'growth stock' or 'value stock' does the greater investing public a disservice.
- InclinedPlane 13y agoAmazon's losses are less than 1% of their revenue. Their net income loss is about 0.06% of their revenues, and less than 1% of their cash on hand, in fact. Amazon isn't losing money, it's operating at break-even to maximize growth. That should be obvious to anyone paying attention. They're growing AWS like crazy. They're expanding into new markets and services. And they're expanding into different countries. They're turning into a remarkably diversified company with both high-volume/low-margin and high-margin businesses. If Amazon were a value stock distributing their profits in the form of dividends then their lack of profit would be a big deal, but it's a growth stock, and their tradeoff of profit in favor of growth is actually welcomed by the market, as evidenced by the stock price.
- simonsarris 13y agoThe missing profit is a blessing for Amazon. None of the other titans are challenging Amazon. They can't because Amazon's Earnings Per Share are... -0.23. Negative 0.23. Investors often lump AMZN with GOOG and the like but GOOG's EPS is 33.59. TGT? 4.26. Walmart is 5.07. No other company with a market cap (100+Bn) as large as AMZN is allowed to get away with negative EPS. The only one that comes close is Vodafone, with a tiny positive EPS (0.13). It's important to note that if any other company spent until their EPS was negative, investors would flip. Amazon is playing with razor thin margins while trying to scale up a platform to end all platforms that we might someday use for everything without thinking about it. If successful, on that day/year/eon dollar bills might as well be printed with Jeff Bezos' face on them. Amazon won't be using UPS and Fedex trucks on that day. They'll be using Amazon trucks. You'll know that era when you see it, I think. If you're Walmart or Target its hard to justify trying to do something similar at this point, the stock could take a major dive from such a risk. They're at the "Ask-questions" phase, and the questions are always "What's the profit?" because these are publicly traded companies. Amazon has been playing it risky since the get-go. Bezos is in for a very long gamble, and that frustrates the hell out of some investors, but its lofty enough to still attract investment dollars while in the "build-first" stage. Hopefully they can pull it off for a few more years before the stock market shifts to asking questions. So Amazon gets to play the long game that other companies are literally disallowed from playing because investors that have seen profits want more. Amazon gets to do something bold that would cause the mother of all stock dives in any other 100+Bn company. They get a free pass because Bezos is convincing and for Amazon its sort-of-always-been-this-way. Walmart/Target/Etc do not have either of those luxuries - the incredible (or believable) visionary and being a company that's still in burn (build) mode. ~~~ All that said, an interesting question I think: What can we do to make more companies like Amazon? And is there a way to allow the older giants (such as Target) to ever be as ambitious again, without huge stock punishment?
- S_A_P 13y agoI think you hit the nail on the head where Amazon needs to go. Logistics and shipping are pretty much where that company must go to continue its path. I wouldnt be surprised if Amazon did try to venture into that arena by acquisition/merger.
- hemancuso 13y agoThe real story is that Amazon is investing every dollar that could be realized as profit back into the company. Completely amazing given the scale. Imagine instead of sitting on a gargantuan pile of cash Apple could figure out how to efficiently invest $150B back into the company [and not through a buyback]. You can argue Amazon doesn't NEED to aggressively expand its warehousing infrastructure if the goal was to turn profit. It doesn't NEED to build AWS or the multitude of other smaller business lines, but it does. A dream for many entrepreneurs is to start a fairly conservative line of business that buys freedom and a stable stream of revenue [consulting, online bookstore] and use the profits to fund a swing-for-the-fences idea. It's absolutely amazing that Amazon keeps that model going decades later.
- tixocloud 13y agoApple does not see opportunity at the moment which is why it's holding the huge amount of cash. And I do recall Steve Jobs giving advice about really focusing on the few things that the company does that makes it so great which would help explain it's huge cash reserves. The company is not trying to enter many different markets all at once.
- nl 13y agoApple does not see opportunity at the moment which is why it's holding the huge amount of cash. Exactly - that's the OP's point. Amazon has the vision to invest its cash in building entire new lines of business, whereas Apple can't see any opportunities.
- tixocloud 13y agoBut it's not Apple's game to play in the things that Amazon plays. Amazon has their own strategy and Apple has their own strategy. Building entire new lines of business is risky and Apple probably does not think that the risk is worth the reward at the end. There's also the question of whether Apple can do as well as Amazon at what it does.
- hershel 13y ago
- netcan 13y agoThere is an argument (I'm not really sure how strong an argument) that this isn't Amazon management's problem, it's investors' problem. Amazon have a strategy which they believe is for the long term good of the company. Sell cheap, grow market share, get more repeat/prime customers, expand (by investing) into new areas. They've been doing that for a good while now. They're profitable. They don't rely on They're growing. It's articulated and consistent. Investors who believe in it, are welcome to buy stock. Those who don't can sell (at a nice, high price)Evidently many do believe. HN likes to bring up fiduciary duty in these cases, but I don't think that extends as far as some comments suggest. Management can't deceive or steal or funnel money to friends. The board has a responsibility to get rid of incompetent managers. None of that is going on here. When it comes to the strategy of the company and decisions like growing market share vs maximizing profits, I think investors vote with their position more than anything else. Another way of looking at it is that "investor" is not a set thing. Different investors have different philosophies and strategies. The ones that like Amazon's strategy are the ones that own the shares in Amazon.
- riggins 13y agoAmazon is an inventory turnover business. This is the fundamental point that's usually not understood. I'll explain by analogy. Assume 2 businesses with the following assumptions Store A: -sells jewelry -capital cost of store is $100K -inventory is $100K (1 turn per year) -annual revenue is $100K -net income margin is 5% -annual net income $5k Store B: -sells pens -capital cost of store is $100K -inventory is the same $100K (they sell a lot of pens) -annual revenue is $500K (5 turns per year) -net income margin is 2.5% -annual net income is $12.5K if you think Store B, the lower margin, higher turnover business, is the better investment, then you get the Amazon investment thesis.
- jacques_chester 13y agoAmazon goes even beyond this; for a lot of products they have a negative operating cycle. They can sell an item, hold the cash, and only pay for it later. Usually companies must internalise the risk and cost of buying stock before they can sell it.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- blt 13y agoDoesn't this same story get posted every few months? Bezos stated that Amazon is re-investing revenue instead of trying to make profit.
- 7Figures2Commas 13y ago> “This isn’t supposed to happen,” said William H. Janeway, an economist and venture capitalist. “It violates mainstream finance theory. Very few companies have been valued this way outside a systemic bubble.” > No one is asserting that Amazon is a flat-out bubble, but there is an increasingly noisy debate about when it will — or even whether it can — deliver the sort of bottom-line profits that investors normally demand from a company expected to post $75 billion in revenue this year. Netflix started the year at under $100/share. It's up to nearly $340/share today. Tesla started the year in the $30s. Its high this year was just under $195/share. Pandora entered 2013 at under $10/share. It's above $26/share today. You can make strong arguments that many tech companies deserve premium valuations. But this market has and is being driven by the Fed so debating fundamentals right now is sort of like talking about a fly on an elephant.
- nikcub 13y agoThe chart in the sidebar says it all: http://imgur.com/edKyuSE.png http://imgur.com/edKyuSE.png as long as Amazon are able to generate that type of return on investment at that scale then they should continue to reinvest all their money back into their businesses. The alternative is to bank the money, miss out on the next AWS or Kindle, give nearly half of it to the tax man, leave 60%+ of it offshore waiting for the next repatriation tax holiday, and only then get a return back which you will then invest in another stock that isn't returning as well or just buy more Amazon stock! Google, Microsoft, Apple et al wish they could invest their cash as well - instead they have to listen to hedge fund managers lobby them for buybacks/dividends etc. because they believe they can invest the money better than Google, Microsoft, Apple can. Given the option, i'd re-up with Bezos every year, his ability to innovate, invest and return is staggering and proven. I really think of Amazon as an investment vehicle (like Berkshire) for web commerce with a strong umbrella brand.