3 ms·
And, in fact, if you'd said that someone had run a CBA on CBAs, I'd have accepted that as your answer. I'm not "determined to turn it into a philosophy of scie
by yummyfajitas 13y ago
And, in fact, if you'd said that someone had run a CBA on CBAs, I'd have accepted that as your answer.
I'm not "determined to turn it into a philosophy of science debate". It became one the moment you questioned computing (benefits - costs) and making decisions based on that.
And we will never come to agreement, given the fact that your meta-epistemiology accepts circular reasoning and mine doesn't. I'm sure if you can find someone else out there who has considered the issue and accepts circular reasoning, you can probably find some justification that you'll accept for CBAs, statistics, controlled experiments and all the rest of it. I suspect you'll have trouble finding this because your meta-epistemiology is rather unique, to say the least.
As for your hypothetical casino, I've never rejected statistics. It's circular reasoning (which you have repeatedly appealed to) that I reject. I don't actually have a meta-epistemiology at all, I simply accept the standard scientific epistemiology and move on with my life.
(Incidentally, if you accept subtraction in addition to counting, together with the idea that costs and benefits are commensurate, you've already justified cost/benefit analysis.)
- phaemon 13y agoRecursive definitions are hardly unique. If you have a problem with them, perhaps you don't understand them properly. Your last statement is false. There doesn't seem much point in continuing this. You've already stated you have no evidence that CBAs work and that's clear enough.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoRecursion has a base case. You don't.