3 ms·
They fined them for losing money? What?
by Houshalter 13y ago
They fined them for losing money? What?
- lmm 13y agoThey fined them for (accidentally) selling shorts they couldn't cover.
- joshAg 13y agoNo, the SEC fined them for losing money stupidly. In order to have access to the market like they did, they had to follow certain laws that are enforced by the SEC. When they were losing all that money they weren't following those laws. It's like if you cause an accident while you're driving by breaking the law; you get a traffic citation (and the accompanying fine), even if your car is totaled as a result of the accident, because you did something illegal.
- Houshalter 13y agoRight but they didn't do anything except offer trades. The thing about selling shorts they couldn't cover makes sense, but just for "acting stupidly" seems silly.
- comrade_ogilvy 13y agoThese are pros who are paid very well to have a clue. It is not silly if "acting stupidly" is described in writing, such that all parties adequately understand when the hammer is likely to come down. I am sure a lot of traders push the envelope and "drive 71 in a 65 mph zone". But it still not silly to give the guy driving 81 a ticket.
- joshAg 13y agosorry, i wasn't sure how detailed to be, but by 'acting stupidly' I meant unintentionally selling shorts they couldn't cover in a way that made the action illegal.
- chalst 13y agoTrading companies are supposed to have effective risk policy (i.e., they are supposed to think about what happens if things do wrong and formulate rules to ameliorate risks) and compliance controls (i.e., bureaucratic controls that ensure that policy actually is followed). The SEC charge does not paint a pretty picture on these counts, but the key point seems to be this one: -- Relied on financial risk controls that were not capable of preventing the entry of orders that exceeded pre-set capital thresholds for the firm in the aggregate. https://www.sec.gov/News/PressRelease/Detail/PressRelease/1370539879795 https://www.sec.gov/News/PressRelease/Detail/PressRelease/13... (The charge also states that Knight violated rules on covering shorts, but I guess this is not so important). The SEC is quite right to fine firms that have lost money with poor risk controls: the point is that bad risk management can hurt the whole sector. It is like fining a factory owner who lets their plant break pollution regulations.