3 ms·
A commodity is something that has no or very little qualitative differentiation. All items are basically the same, and suppliers therefore compete only on price
by fauigerzigerk 17y ago
A commodity is something that has no or very little qualitative differentiation. All items are basically the same, and suppliers therefore compete only on price. So what is that uniform quality of all web apps that makes them completely interchangeable? If you can name it, I would say yes, web apps are commodities. Otherwise they are not commodities and it is irrelevant that they are easier to make than a few years ago (if that's actually the case)
- ctb9 17y agoExactly. Just because the cost to produce a web app is approaching zero does not imply that web apps are becoming more homogeneous. If anything, the opposite is the case, as a reduction in the time/effort to turn an idea into a reality results in more variation. The increasing ease of copying other people's ideas is the one mechanism by which improving technology does make webapps more similar. However, copying others has never been particularly difficult, and gaining a first-mover advantage, especially in high-margin or community-based apps, should provide sufficient reward for innovation.
- stcredzero 17y agoMost webapps are mostly CRUD, with a few specialized screens and a few Roles. Plastic is a commodity. Injection molded plastic comes in a variety of colors, shapes, and densities. It can be used to create very specialized parts/products. Perhaps my question is misphrased. Perhaps I should have asked, "Is web app programming a commodity?"
- thetrumanshow 17y agoPlastic, at least, has to be formed into a product by someone. The value derrived from act of forming something depends on the output of the process. Therefore, the act of forming has little value if the output is of little value to the market. What you're observing in our industry, likely without realizing it, is that no one is innovating. There are no Thomas Edisons.
- fauigerzigerk 17y agoYes I think that's a much better question. If web app programming was a commodity it would mean that any programmer could make equally good web apps with the available tools. But I think the answer is still no. My perception is that the difference between good and bad web apps is vast. 80% of the web apps I have ever used are hardly usable at all.