3 ms·
Well, they aren't, especially compared to Americans as he points out. In fact, can we name any big ones that don't make hardware? I can't think of any off the
by hga 13y ago
Well, they aren't, especially compared to Americans as he points out. In fact, can we name any big ones that don't make hardware? I can't think of any off the top of my head, especially web site companies, but feel free to jog my memory.
His comment is also highly qualified, "a little bit absurd". And people not of the right are e.g. pointing out CGI proper recently getting fired by a province? for botching a contract.
And while I've been railing about the management problems above them, we've been hearing about a lot of issues at their level, the most recent here from one of our members: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6583778 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6583778
This is not my field of expertise (I'm a back end guy and last worked at this level in 1997), but ... I don't think I've heard anything good, and I've heard a lot of things that seem to be inexcusable. Possibly process issues, going into production without testing, but that should be limited to CGI Federal, not the misbegotten integrator, HHS's CMMS. Well, except for the "we're not going to test this until the week before launch" minor detail....
Disclaimer: I worked for a short while for a part of AMS that didn't get bought by CGI. But they did seem to be above average in competence as Beltway Bandits go.
- tptacek 13y agoYou realize that the "they" in my quote refers to Canadians in general, right?
- hga 13y agoIf they're technical they aren't expressing it in Canada, are they? 1/10 the population, very roughly 1/10 the GDP, but not even a fraction of 1/10 the visible (computer) high tech, right? Given how qualified, that is "weak", his statement was, the point I'm making is I believe apropos. It's a jab at our Tory neighbors to north, not some profound judgement of CGI's abilities. And in the political arena certainly you must be expecting such jabs?
- o0-0o 13y agoDid you edit your quote and remove the word "they"?
- loumf 13y agoOpenText is a web pioneer that went a different route to search engine monetization. We can nitpick on exactly how successful they are, but they are undoubtedly big and a website company http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open_Text_Corporation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open_Text_Corporation
- hga 13y agoThe University of Waterloo has long been known as a center of text search excellence. Independent, perhaps, of the OED work (which I used in a smaller Oxford American? English dictionary product, I sure wish I could justify buying the OED :-( ), I remember a talk or paper about a very cool method developed there and/or by one of the companies, I seem to vaguely remember it used patricia tries. And I'm happy to see all that turned into a very successful company, 1 billion revenue and 123 profit FY 11, over 5,000 employees in 2012. But all that said, per Wikipedia, it "is Canada's largest software company", which supports the general point. At least in Canada, we don't see the 1/10 of the American level of success we might expect, although I wouldn't be surprised if the "Canadians" situation looked a lot better if a good expat study was done, over the years I've known a number of top notch Canadian software engineers working here---which itself could be telling. But the country itself, as a big source of computer technological excellence? Sorry....
- loumf 13y agoCanada has 1/10th the population of the US. I'm not saying the country is on par with the US, but it's not crazy to think that there's a Canadian company with expertise in government healthcare software. I wouldn't feel better knowing this contract went to one of the many big US government contractors, and wouldn't be surprised to get a similar result.
- hga 13y agoWell, CGI Federal started as the civilian part of American Management Systems (AMS http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Management_Systems http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Management_Systems) in 2004, so it's kind of both (I was in a national security unit of AMS that got sold to the US firm CACI, although I declined to make that jump). CGI Federal is (at least now) responsible for CMS.gov and Medicare.gov. I can attest that the latter site's claims and Plan D (prescription plan selection) parts work well, even if they're a bit clunky. So sole-sourcing this part of Healthcare.gov to CGI Federal was not dumb at all. What was and still is dumb is having a bunch of unqualified federal bureaucrats and political appointees manage the whole thing (HHS s CMS and on up to the White House) play the role of integrator including integration testing (as is common in these political waterfall projects, why even bother when test failures have no effect on rollout???). CGI Federal? A Google/Facebook/Lisper dream team? You can't win when your customer makes major changes throughout the process, right through the week before launch. And apparently ignores every warning everyone makes, not to mention those failed tests.