3 ms·
"As ever more opt out, the larger culture is damaged." What is the larger culture? Those who've opted out of the real world and into primetime TV, rabid sport
by VLM 13y ago
"As ever more opt out, the larger culture is damaged."
What is the larger culture? Those who've opted out of the real world and into primetime TV, rabid sports fans, and social drinkers. Those opt out activities are much more popular than EVEonline or the other examples and would seem like a much better essay topic, certainly more raw material.
Fox news viewers outnumber active EVE players by an order of magnitude, as just one of a zillion examples, and certainly are not any closer connected to reality.
"gamer after gamer was now playing alone"
You can draw almost the same argument from live plays, to movie theaters, to "the" family TV, to watching TV alone.
How about the trend of sports are something you play, then something you watch your neighbors play, then something you watch regional teams play, then something you watch in a bar with an expensive radio, later expensive TV, finally sports are something you watch alone at home on TV.
Meanwhile in both examples, the real world goes on, outside.
You'll have about 100 times more data and over a longer time interval to gather data. Seems a little overly trendy to grab an inferior topic instead.
- pharrington 13y agoWe're human beings. We're social animals. Popular culture is just as real as nature. Popular culture is a popular way to connect with other people. And for your example of Fox News, while that certainly is toxic to society, the salient element of that toxicity is not the popularity. The article is about increasing hyper-specialization to the point of extreme isolation.
- cortesoft 13y agoYes, we are social animals, but for much of our evolution we were social in much, much smaller groups... even smaller than these 'sub' cultures the article is talking about. Hunter-gatherer societies only had around 10-50 people in each group; we have evolved to be social in groups of this size. The 'hyper-specialization' that you speak of might be a way to get our group size back to this original size that we have evolved to be comfortable in; the huge, un-natural, size of popular culture might be what we are reacting against.
- pharrington 13y agoThe hyper-specialization we're talking about is specifically a way to avoid having a social group. While the hikikomori may not have exclusive interests, the whole point is to avoid physical contact with anyone at all. Maaaaybe I just can't see far enough into the future, but personally I think physical contact with other people is still pretty important. Also partaking in popular culture doesn't mean pulling everyone alive that's interested in that culture into your social group.
- MarkTee 13y agoDunbar's number (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunbar's_number http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunbar's_number). The average person can only maintain 150 relationships; how is popular culture (which is composed of thousands or even millions of people) closer to nature than isolationism?