4 ms·
> If everyone was driving light fuel-efficient cars, then engineering quality, not greater mass, would be the dominant safety factor for the buyer. Light fuel
by anamax 17y ago
> If everyone was driving light fuel-efficient cars, then engineering quality, not greater mass, would be the dominant safety factor for the buyer.
Light fuel-efficient cars don't meet everyone's needs. (Yup, mom-mobiles/mini-vans are needed.) And few people can afford to have both a commute car and an "everything else" car per daily-driver. (Besides, a commute-only vehicle means that you can't do as much in transit.)
Besides, the "if everyone drove small, everyone would be safe" assumption is wrong because many car accidents don't involve another car.
I'm unaware of significant efforts to make "not cars" (not just trucks, but immobile structures) more crash friendly. (Yes, I know about break-away traffic signs. Even if all signs were break-away, that wouldn't be enough.)
- stcredzero 17y agoBesides, the "if everyone drove small, everyone would be safe" assumption is wrong because many car accidents don't involve another car. Lose points for misreading and putting words in my mouth. I said that, "engineering quality, not greater mass, would be the dominant safety factor for the buyer." It is the prevalence of large passenger vehicles that makes greater mass an issue in North America. I wouldn't see so many small single women driving around alone in Suburbans, Expeditions, and other SUVs if there wasn't an on-road arms race here in terms of vehicle mass. I've spoken with two other people who have been in major collisions in a little teeny Honda CRX. The engine dropped out the bottom of the car, the front end crumpled, and everything happened exactly like it was supposed to, and everyone came out mostly unscathed. Consumers here as a whole would be much better served by paying attention to the safety engineering of vehicles, instead of just feeling secure because they are perched high in a huge metal behemoth. No scheme or factor is going to make everyone safe. Don't put that straw man on me. More consumer attention to safety engineering is going to ground the market on more economical principles, however.
- stonemetal 17y ago>>"engineering quality, not greater mass, would be the dominant safety factor for the buyer." Nope, people want to feel safe not be safe.
- anamax 17y ago> Lose points for misreading and putting words in my mouth. I said that, "engineering quality, not greater mass, would be the dominant safety factor for the buyer." It is the prevalence of large passenger vehicles that makes greater mass an issue in North America. Lose points for continuming to assert something after being told of counter examples. Trucks exist. So do overpass supports. All other things being equal, mass and distance helps. Bigger vehicles provide more of both. But, let's not stop there. > I wouldn't see so many small single women driving around alone in Suburbans, Expeditions, and other SUVs if there wasn't an on-road arms race here in terms of vehicle mass. You're assuming something about them that's false. The fact that someone is driving alone doesn't mean that said someone always drives alone. Do you really think that they should drive the kids to {wherever}, leave the car and take the bus home and then take the bus back to pick them up? Besides, I've shown the arithmetic - it rarely makes sense to buy an extra car to save gas - the other costs dwarf the savings.
- stcredzero 17y agoLose points for continuming to assert something after being told of counter examples. No, you still don't get it. I'm talking about motivation, not about safety directly. If the motivations of consumers are misplaced, it's harder for the market to work from the right ones. Trucks exist. So do overpass supports. All other things being equal, mass and distance helps. Bigger vehicles provide more of both. Yes, mass matters in a collision. I never said it doesn't. I paid attention to momentum in high school physics. Again, it's the prevalence of large vehicles that's the issue. It's the distortion of the North American market that causes many more large vehicles than are actually needed to be on the road. You're assuming something about them that's false. The fact that someone is driving alone doesn't mean that said someone always drives alone. Uh, you're assuming the opposite? I'm not assuming anything about a particular individual. I estimate that the prevalence of the phenomenon is out of whack. Please stop putting inaccurate renditions of my ideas into my mouth! Step 1 - misread other's post. Step 2 - respond to the distorted/simplistic idea you just misread. Step 3 - repeat until you feel smart. Look, if your brain can't handle the one level of indirection involved with prevalence or motivations in a market, then get out and go back to the mental kiddie pool. At least criticize me for using mental impressions of prevalence instead of hard numbers. Then you'd be actually criticizing my actual idea and not your misreading. Tiresome.