4 ms·
Wikipedia should indeed be more alert to paid editing. Its commonly discussed in the village, Jim's talk page and other places (blogs, podcasts and so on). So f
by belorn 13y ago
Wikipedia should indeed be more alert to paid editing. Its commonly discussed in the village, Jim's talk page and other places (blogs, podcasts and so on). So far no definitive decision has been reached, and for good and bad, paid edits are evaluated on the basis of content rather than the motives behind the edit.
However, the admin process is not exactly an easy one ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WP:RFA_Guide https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WP:RFA_Guide). Added that administrators are viewed under harsher light regarding civility (they can and do get banned for actions that non-admins don't), and the refresh rate of new administrators is indeed slow.
> At least some of the administrators have been caught taking payoffs for editing articles to publicize the persons making the payoffs.
Did those administrators retain their administrator status? If so, then the community is working as intended. Just because HN successfully ban people for spamming on hacker news, it doesn't make HN a failed community. Why would wikipedia have failed because they too managed to ban people acting in contrast to the project?
- tommorris 13y agoI'm an admin. My RfA went swimmingly (97 supports, 1 oppose, 3 neutrals). But even though it went well, it was still nerve-wracking. Much more nerve-wracking than any job interview I've ever had. A week-long process where everyone is looking for examples of when you've fucked up and asking questions to try and trip you up. I can understand why people are reluctant to run for adminship.