5 ms·
> It is hard to argue with what is unfolding before our very eyes What we are seeing right now (~.5B waste) is a drop in the bucket compared to waste in the U
by jjoonathan 13y ago
> It is hard to argue with what is unfolding before our very eyes
What we are seeing right now (~.5B waste) is a drop in the bucket compared to waste in the US system as compared to socialized systems. We pay ~2x as much for comparable health care (per person per mean PPP-adjusted GDP/capita) [1]. That is about 250b/yr we are spending on a (more closely) free market system that keeps promising to be more efficient than its social counterparts and keeps failing to deliver, or even deliver in the same ballpark. I realize that HN is a site about code, but it's important to keep some perspective here. $500M (itself an inflated figure) is 0.2% of $250b. If it is hard to ague against $500M of waste, it surely must be nearly impossible to argue against $250b of yearly, recurring waste, no? How do you ignore these figures?!
If you're going to argue that our system makes up the difference with better outcomes, I want to see numbers. I happen to know that they don't support this argument, but I want you to do the search so that you can't dismiss my sources by assuming they were cherry-picked.
> I happen to think ... Free market decentralized healthcare ... would have been a far better approach
Of course, $250b/yr includes the cost of providing care as well as administration. Perhaps administration of a free market system is more efficient? Not when you compare the US (31% administrative overhead) to Canada (16.7%) or the UK (6%) [2], [3]. This isn't a surprising result, either: I recently listed 7 reasons why exchanges should be more efficient than current individual plans [4] and you can add the profit margin and advertising costs to that list to come up with 9 advantages a single-payer system would have over a free market health care system.
Markets are good at optimizing things that can be quantified, so perhaps a better comparison would be between medicare and private insurance (not overall administration, just the insurance part). Again, the government systems come out ahead: Medicare overhead is 3.6%, Canada's insurance-related overhead is 1.3%, and overhead among private US insurers is 11.7% [2].
> Cheaper, faster, better. All three.
[citation needed]
See [5] for a more complete overview of the pro-single-payer argument and a truckload of reputably-sourced studies and comparisons (as opposed to hand-wavey promises) to back it up.
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_total_health_expenditure_%28PPP%29_per_capita http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_total_heal...
[2] http://www.pnhp.org/single_payer_resources/administrative_waste_consumes_31_percent_of_health_spending.php http://www.pnhp.org/single_payer_resources/administrative_wa...
[3] http://nhsrationing.org/tag/administrative-costs/ http://nhsrationing.org/tag/administrative-costs/
[4] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6582753 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6582753
[5] http://www.pnhp.org/facts/single-payer-resources http://www.pnhp.org/facts/single-payer-resources
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- robomartin 13y ago>> Cheaper, faster, better. All three. > [citation needed] Lookup the history of laser eye surgery over the last, say, ten years. Free markets work. That's irrefutable. The problem is we've never had a free market system when it comes to medicine.
- jjoonathan 13y agoYou're cherry picking: laser eye surgery has effective competition, elastic demand, no information asymmetry, and it is priced well within the annual (even monthly) earning potential of most Americans. It's a service that I would expect the free market to be able to provide efficiently and it does not surprise me that it succeeds. The free market is very good at optimizing value creation under certain circumstances and it's great that laser eye surgery matches up with those requirements. Unfortunately, when it comes to policy we do not get to cherry-pick the conditions under which the rest of the system operates, and the other parts of the health care market run under conditions that demonstrably throw the free market for a loop (hence the system-level failures vs socialized systems I pointed out above). Cancer treatments cannot be paid for out of most people's savings. "Customers" do not always have the chance to shop around between providers (w/o insurance) and those that do use insurance experience a 99% deleveraging effect because only the 1% that have extraordinary costs are in a position to examine the value of what they bought. Do you have a proposed mechanism of breaking information asymmetries, re-leveraging disproportionately expensive consumers, and standardizing the coverage provided by free market plans? Do you have a way of pricing the 5 externalities I listed into the insurance providers' budgets? Has your proposal been implemented in a dozen other countries and proven to be comparatively cost effective for decades? What is your answer to the figures that show that our system in aggregate is 2-10x less efficient than comparable social systems? Anybody can cherry pick a counterexample. Anybody can speculatively extrapolate it out to a convenient conclusion. But the single-payer advocates can point to a mountain of directly relevant apples-to-apples evidence regarding the industry as a whole that does not require extrapolating across markets or cherry picking conditions / good years. To me, it appears to be a mountain of evidence vs a pebble. Do you really think the the implicit strength of extrapolation from the (very) special case of laser eye surgery carries weight against these empirical apples-to-apples comparisons?