4 ms·
Why Do We Have Fingerprints?
- dinkumthinkum 17y agoThere's no reason to think that all adaptations are beneficial. Interesting though.
- scott_s 17y agoAdaptations are, by definition, beneficial. There will be evolutionary by-products, though; things that arise because of evolution, but there was no actual selection pressure for them. Some changes occur because of genetic drift, and others will be related to something else which was selected for.
- michael_dorfman 17y agoOK, let's rephrase, then: there's no reason to think that fingerprints are an adaptation.
- scott_s 17y agoYou mean there's not enough evidence either way. Which is why it's useful to investigate if fingerprints do have a benefit. If they do, then that's a compelling reason that they are an adaptation.
- wglb 17y agoSo it seems to me that friction is a pretty dicey thing to measure. It seems that friction is really a property of each of the two surfaces. For example, if we are measuring the friction between fingers and a smooth surface, you would notice that fingerprints reduce the friction. But what about the hand gripping a tree branch? Might not the friction be increased in that sort of surface-to-surface contact? Or hanging onto a hunk of the fur of a running buffalo for dear life? Their approach seems to imply relatively smooth surfaces: "Because there are all the gaps between the fingerprints, what they do is reduce the contact area with the surface" I am not seeing any reference to the fractal nature of surface-to-surface contact here.
- Retric 17y agoAlso grip tends to have little to do with friction. When moving heavy objects you curl your fingers around it vs. laying your hand flat and trusting in friction. If anything reducing friction might be a good idea because you can better position your hands for optimum grip. Edit: When you move a couch you curl you fingers under an edge, hold onto a tree branch you curl your fingers around it etc. Climbing a tree can involve friction but usually it’s griping the texture of the bark. PS: Consider how you would hold a wet wine glass.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoFor heavy objects, it's probably not so relevant. But in my experience, more friction would probably be useful when holding tools/weapons. Hammers have a rubber grip, for example. I've noticed I lose smooth eskrima sticks far more often than ones I've taped. In an natural selection event, that could be lethal [1]. [1] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c_qwaXb6kAE http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c_qwaXb6kAE
- scott_s 17y agoI have to disagree based on my weightlifting experience. When deadlifting heavy weight (1.5x bodyweight and higher), friction makes a big impact on my grip. Sweaty hands, and even a bar with worn-down grooves, can significantly degrade my grip. This is why weightlifters (and gymnasts) use chalk.
- Retric 17y agoChalk does not maximize friction in all cases. With light pressure chalk reduces friction, under heavy pressure it increases it. Which is clearly a best case situation. As an example of this pool players use chalk to smoooth out their stroke.
- scott_s 17y agoI don't think that's a function of pressure, but amount. If my hands were caked in chalk, I probably would have a harder time maintaining grip. But if I have just enough to maintain dry hands, but not enough to reduce friction, then it helps.
- ComputerGuru 17y agoIntelligent design proponents typically point at the fingerprint as something evolution doesn't well explain and proof of ID. The Muslim's Quran speaks of the fingerprint as a miracle of God's creation, pointing out the attention to the finest details as proof of God's capabilities.
- biohacker42 17y agoI guess the blind spot on our retinas also must show the super intelligent attention to detail.
- michael_dorfman 17y agoIf there was a designer of the human, "intelligent" isn't the adjective I'd use-- it seems more hacked together than engineered....
- TheSOB88 17y agocomment = new Comment( parent ); comment.sarcasm = 0; //does this work? check later
- dinkumthinkum 17y agoThat doesn't really make sense though. Strictly speaking, evolutionary theory and natural selection, etc describe a theory about a process. I don't think the veracity of evolutionary theory or the explanatory power of it is contingent on how well proponents of it can evaluate the specific "uses" of adapatations. ID is such a reactionary and contentless view that I find them actually far sillier than outright creationists like Kent Hovind; at least they are honest.
- jpwagner 17y agoEvolution suggests that convergence occurs with the best adaptation. If you take for granted that striated prints are better than smooth ones, it seems obvious that fingerprints would be nearly random striations because converging the design has no benefit (ie randomness is the norm, not convergence.)
- sp332 17y agoThey're for sensing textures and other vibration filtering: http://www.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/abstract/323/5920/1503 http://www.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/abstract/323/5920/1503 ( DOI 10.1126/science.1166467 )
- aptimpropriety 17y agoMy initial reaction was to think about dealing with dirt. Ever try to maintain grip on a very smooth surface covered with a thin layer of dirt/dust? On fingers, this stuff slides into the 'crevasses' of the print. Extremely pseudo-science, but in my 2 minutes of thinking seems like it could be worth a thought. I'm sure those scientists used clean hands on their testing papers.