6 ms·
Is Wikipedia for Sale?
- mjn 13y agoOne mitigating factor (though not as mitigating as I'd like) is that PR fluff, at least of the direct-editing variety (versus placing positive media articles that then get cited in Wikipedia) tends to be most successful on the articles people read least. If a country hires a PR firm to insert propaganda into an article on an ongoing international conflict, it's much more likely to get removed or modified, vs. if an obscure company hires a PR firm to fluff its Wikipedia article. Likewise a major company like Microsoft or Google will have a harder time fluffing its article than the obscure company would, because more people are watching and editing the Microsoft/Google pages. One area where it comes up a lot is that a bunch of academics' articles are total fluff written by the university communications department, but also, nobody reads or cares about those articles. There are admittedly areas where that isn't true, articles with many readers but relatively little editor interest. Some tourist destinations are like that: lots of people may google for them, but there often isn't very much to write about them in good, cited sources. So they get relatively little legitimate editing, and lots of travel spam. I personally make it a point to systematically go through the pages on Greek islands and island villages once a year or so to clear out the hotel/car-rental/etc. spam.
- ilamont 13y agoThe fact that companies, politicians, and other interests are paying PR people to edit or create articles shouldn't come as a surprise. Take a look at almost any living famous person's profile, and chances are you'll see a large amount of spin and fluff. And let's not forget the 2012 PR scandal involving a trustee of the Wikimedia Foundation UK and a Wikipedian In Residence who were "allegedly editing Wikipedia pages and facilitating front-page placement for their pay-for-play, publicity-seeking clients."(1) PR also makes it into Wikipedia through sanctioned channels -- namely mass media citations which are considered "reliable sources", even though the content of the citation comes from a press release or helpful PR person. This brings up an issue related to Wikipedia's policy that requires substantial third-party coverage for new articles. It is a flawed test for the importance of a subject. Press coverage tends toward the sensational, visual, beautiful, controversial, current, language-specific, and easily explained. If a topic doesn't meet those criteria, it probably won't be covered by the press -- unless the topic in question has some well-connected PR firm or publicist pushing for it. Another issue with press coverage is "established" media is contracting. There aren't as many editors assigning stories, or reporters crafting unbiased profiles of companies, organizations, topics and people. This has an significant, indirect impact on the types of topics that can be sourced according to Wikipedia's official rules. 1. http://news.cnet.com/8301-1023_3-57514677-93/corruption-in-wikiland-paid-pr-scandal-erupts-at-wikipedia/ http://news.cnet.com/8301-1023_3-57514677-93/corruption-in-w...
- mjn 13y agoThis brings up an issue related to Wikipedia's policy that requires substantial third-party coverage for new articles. It is a flawed test for the importance of a subject. I don't think it's best interpreted as a test for the importance of a subject, although I'll admit that some Wikipedians do view it that way, and some policy pages (especially older ones) seem to do so as well. To me the more defensible line is just that it's a test of whether there exist sufficient sources for an article with its information properly cited to be written at all. If there are halfway decent third-party sources, one can be written, of some kind of level of quality, transitively dependent on the quality of those sources. If there are no decent third-party sources at all, then there is no basis for writing an article, since Wikipedia articles are supposed to be verifiable, i.e. everything they claim should be cited to something other than Wikipedia itself (and not the personal knowledge of the Wikipedian who wrote the article, either). I wrote a longish essay arguing this in some more detail, that the 'verifiability' guideline has basically swallowed the 'notability' guideline in practice. But this leaves a gap of things that are clearly notable, but lack good sources about them. In that case Wikipedia is stuck between not covering a notable subject (bad), or covering it in an article that isn't properly cited (also bad). http://www.kmjn.org/notes/wikipedia_notability_verifiability.html http://www.kmjn.org/notes/wikipedia_notability_verifiability... The reverse case, where a not-really-notable subject is covered because there are sources, I feel is less bad. If the external world is writing about a subject, then imo it's fine that Wikipedia summarizes what they have said about it. At the very least, many such things (like celebrity missing-child cases and vaporware tech companies and whatnot) are meta-notable for the media attention.
- swalling 13y ago"Take a look at almost any living famous person's profile and chances are you'll see a large amount of spin and fluff." Citation needed. According to recent traffic reports,[1] some of the most popular biographies of living people recently are as follows: - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lorde https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lorde (449,871 views) - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malala_Yousafzai https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malala_Yousafzai (362,657 views) - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miley_Cyrus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miley_Cyrus (342,994 views) Other popular bios include Barack Obama and Ted Cruz. Obviously popularity of these swings heavily toward recent news items in most cases. Now, I wouldn't argue against the assertion that fans of these celebrities have written in some amazing fluff in these articles. But you'd really claim that these articles have been spun by PR people? Looking at the history and the content, I seriously doubt it. Now, if you don't care for how Wikipedia's reliance on third party sources bends content... well, there's not much anyone can do to help you. That's a problem of the media environment Wikipedia exists in, and you haven't really proposed a viable alternative to relying on secondary source material. The way we correct for bias in sources is to use more sources, and be selective about ones we use, taking in to account the fact that some are highly unreliable. In the end, if you have a problem with how Wikipedia relies on certain sources or what it says on certain articles, there's an easy solution: edit the damn thing. I don't particularly care about the Miley Cyrus article, but if I did, I'd be doing something about it. Wikipedia's best defense against fluff, spin, and PR influence is for smart people (like Hacker News denizens) to participate. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Wikipedia_Signpost/2013-10-16/Traffic_report https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Wikipedia_Signpost/2...
- alecdbrooks 13y agoI enjoyed the article for the interesting story and its description of how PR manipulation of Wikipedia works, but its speculation on how the problem is getting worse was entirely unsubstantiated. It's plausible enough that efforts by Wiki PR and similar firms are growing, but the article didn't offer any evidence or attribute claims like "In a few years, a significant percentage of Wikipedia’s content could be spam." Given that Wiki PR seems to have had little success getting articles reinstated, it may be that the problem will be held at bay now that Wikipedia contributors have been alerted.
- th3iedkid 13y agoone evidence was from a contributor who quit.Being volunteers not everyone likes to be only cleaning someone's mess.Besides scale of Wikipedia might grow quite big for the 10,000 odd admins to manage and who know how seepage might happen!Also Wiki-PR was one, who knows how many more are left!
- alecdbrooks 13y ago>Also Wiki-PR was one, who knows how many more are left! That's exactly my point. From the article, we don't know if there are enough companies doing this to pose a serious threat to Wikipedia, yet it suggests there is.
- tokenadult 13y agoMy experience as a Wikipedian suggests that Wikipedia's administrators need to be much more alert than they have been to the possibility that the Wikipedians motivated by money (or by ideological bias) will stay with the project and persist in making edits contrary to Wikipedia policy. They edit more articles, and edit in greater numbers, than most admins guess or notice. And the point-of-view-pushing editors often inject so much wikidrama into discussions about how to improve articles that they drive away the participation of conscientious editors who know reliable sources about the article topics. A current example is the article on Rupert Sheldrake,[1] which has recently been subjected to vigorous edit-warring, perhaps as part of a publicity campaign by followers of Sheldrake. (I just saw a new book by Sheldrake at a library yesterday, and perhaps that book's publication set the timing for the editing push.) But there are examples like this all over Wikipedia, and, again, I think most casual users of Wikipedia massively underestimate the percentage of articles that are edited mostly in the interest of pushing a point of view for commercial or ideological reasons. The article kindly submitted here says, "Anyone can edit Wikipedia, but only a carefully vetted few are promoted to admin status on the site." And that is laughable. Describing the current group of Wikipedia as "a carefully vetted few" does violence to the English language. Nothing has ever been careful about the process for checking the background of administrator candidates or choosing which candidates become administrators. There are some very, very, very good administrators on Wikipedia (just as there are many very helpful everyday volunteer editors), but there are other administrators who are power trips to maintain conduct contrary to Wikipedia policies for building a good, free online encyclopedia. The Vice article submitted here does, at least, link to an Atlantic article[2] reporting that Wikipedia's rate of bringing new administrators on board is slowing. At least some of the administrators have been caught taking payoffs for editing articles to publicize the persons making the payoffs, so it will take more than just the current administrators being more alert to fix this problem on Wikipedia. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rupert_Sheldrake https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rupert_Sheldrake [2] http://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2012/07/3-charts-that-show-how-wikipedia-is-running-out-of-admins/259829/ http://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2012/07/3-char...
- kops 13y agoI look at wikipedia as a cafe where intellectuals come and chat. Do I want to continue listening to this chatter? Hell Yes. Nothing else comes even close in terms accessibility. Will I stake my life on the information taken from wikipedia? Absolutely not. I wouldn't even cite it as a reference anywhere.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- avty 13y agoWikipedia is already morally sold to PR interests.
- yuvipanda 13y agoCan you expand on why/how?
- spanishcow 13y agoThe problem is as old as mass media. The solution is the same. Make it illegal for a company pass advertisments as casual forum comments, wikipedia articles and generally forbid misleding the general public to believe that actual advertisments are part of other natural interactions. (This doesn't means that this practices will stop but that them can be punished) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advertorial#Legal_issues http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advertorial#Legal_issues
- GhotiFish 13y agoThat is a very good idea. I would love to see astroturfing be punishable.
- glesica 13y agoWhy not just make the terms of service say something like "you agree not to edit the encyclopedia for money, and you agree not to pay anyone else to do so, etc." and then start suing people? As a bonus, no one could claim ignorance once the lawsuits started flying, everyone in the PR industry would know about it. The courts seem intent on giving more and more credence to ToS, might as well use that for something good.
- swalling 13y agoThere are related terms in the current Terms of Use, namely that you may not edit "With the intent to deceive, posting content that is false or inaccurate" and that also disallowed is "Attempting to impersonate another user or individual, misrepresenting your affiliation with any individual or entity, or using the username of another user with the intent to deceive;"[1] So in other words, deliberate falsehoods or manipulation by PR people or paid agents that hide their affiliation with a company is already a ToU violation. 1. https://wikimediafoundation.org/wiki/Terms_of_Use https://wikimediafoundation.org/wiki/Terms_of_Use
- mjn 13y agoThat's true, although I think it would cause a huge controversy to sue someone over it (rather than just banning them). It implicates all sorts of questions that are already controversial in the free-culture community, like to what extent ToS should be legally enforceable as contracts. Even worse if the editor is from outside the U.S., and controversy over extraterritorial application of U.S. law gets implicated.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- guynamedloren 13y agoThis is why I think a GitHub-style model is more suitable for certain open, collaborative information - it's simply less prone to abuse. The editing and submission process is significantly more structured than a wiki, which prevents attacks like this.
- tommorris 13y agoWikipedia has "pending changes" which is a bit like a pull request type model: you make edit and it sits in a queue for a reviewer to approve. It's running on some pages on English Wikipedia. I'd love to see it rolled out to a lot more pages. On some language versions of Wikipedia, it's running on all pages: Polish, for instance.
- nl 13y agoI'd love to tackle this problem using "Big Data" techniques. It's pretty clear from this story and from things like the Morning277 sockpuppet investigation[1] that the manual style of investigation to so time consuming and slow that it limits the ability of Wikipedia to fix problems like this. While tools like CheckUser[2] help, it seems likely that a lot more of the "legwork" associated with the investigation could also be automated. At the core, much of the work is network analysis, and that is something computers are better at than humans. [1] http://www.dailydot.com/lifestyle/wikipedia-sockpuppet-investigation-largest-network-history-wiki-pr/ http://www.dailydot.com/lifestyle/wikipedia-sockpuppet-inves... [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:CheckUser http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:CheckUser
- swalling 13y agoWikimedia also provides several sources of data and infrastructure for hosting potential tools like this, if you'd like to take it on. In addition to public data streams like RecentChanges and public API access, we provide hosting infrastructure in the form of Labs (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Wikimedia_Labs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Wikimedia_Labs). Not to mention the fact that anyone can write and submit a MediaWiki extension that could get deployed to Wikipedia itself. One related piece of infrastructure is the automated tagging of edits. There are already several tags automatically applied to edits with a suspected conflict of interest regarding linking or autobiographies (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Tags https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Tags).
- ilovecookies 13y agoFunny that no-one mentioned the fact that the page had a brazilian flag. Musicians has the right by law to veto biographies and personal information written about them in brazil, this also applies to brazilian webpages. It could be understandable that these people would make out a big chunk of the customers for a company as wiki-pr hence the page's Portuguese translation.
- sgentle 13y agoI'm surprised that Wikipedia hasn't found a way to integrate and regulate paid PR people. It's naive to think they're going to go away just because it'd be better if they did. Why not work with them instead? PR people could publicly register themselves as such and, in exchange for extra scrutiny, have a chance to prove themselves as ethical and willing to follow the rules. These people would then build a reputation as very valuable "white hats", willing to help people and companies with their Wikipedia page without compromising the integrity of the encyclopedia. They wouldn't be able to guarantee "we'll make sure you look good on Wikipedia", but then nobody can really guarantee that anyway. Instead, they could offer to ensure the page is as unbiased as possible, help protect it from vandalism, and generally improve its quality and detail. This could lead to a large and very motivated base of editors with a significant personal and financial incentive to do the right thing (or lose their white hat status) and sabotage the financial incentives that currently motivate the black hat firms.