3 ms·
Should the title be updated to reflect that this is 2+ months old? After all, the fix was put in place in a couple of hours. This isn't a current bug, but rathe
by bdcravens 13y ago
Should the title be updated to reflect that this is 2+ months old? After all, the fix was put in place in a couple of hours. This isn't a current bug, but rather, an excellent post-mortem, but the title suggests present tense.
- adamnemecek 13y agoThe write up is from yesterday about a bug fixed a while back, as per responsible disclosure.
- ParkerK 13y agoMost responsible disclosure is normally posted about sooner though. I think what the OP meant is that waiting 2 months later, and then giving the post this title, makes it seem as though it was a more recent bug
- franjkovic 13y agoActually I waited until we pushed Pyxio website on-line. Since I am not native English speaker, what would be best replacement for current title?
- Miyamoto 13y ago"Post-mortem" is usually appended to titles for solved vulnerabilities, although this was 2 months ago. Maybe just timestamp it? e.g. "Facebook CSRF leading to full account takeover (Post-mortem, August 2013)"
- lambada 13y agoThat would imply that the Post-Mortem itself was written in August 2013, which would probably get far fewer clicks as people assume they've read about the vulnerability before.
- rmc 13y agoAnyone who writes about security bugs like this where it's a "current bug" is being shitty. Follow responsible disclosure, people.
- jrochkind1 13y agoIf you read the OP, you'll find that's what happened.
- rmc 13y agoOh I agree. I was directing my comment at the comment I replied to, which was bemoaning that this wasn't a current bug. It was like they were complaining that responsible disclosure wasn't followed.
- bdcravens 13y agoI wasn't at all suggesting disclosing a bug before it's fixed. The write-up was great, the disclosure correct. I was merely saying that the HN title should reflect the current state of affairs.
- Zoomla 13y agoDo you really expect to learn about open bugs by reading HN?