4 ms·
> i used to be more sympathetic to criticisms of DSM-V, but a couple of months back i went to see a psychiatrist. who told me he didn't believe in it. fair enou
by Alex3917 13y ago
> i used to be more sympathetic to criticisms of DSM-V, but a couple of months back i went to see a psychiatrist. who told me he didn't believe in it. fair enough. but he then diagnosed me with something and prescribed me a drug. when i asked why, he said i should trust his intuition. without DSM-V or anything similar there was no structure - nothing i could understand or question. no logic. just "intuition".
You do realize that one of the biggest criticisms of the DSM-5 is that the inter-rater reliability for many diagnoses is no better than a coin flip, right?
- andrewcooke 13y agothen fix those, but don't throw the baby out with the bathwater. the problem is that, at least in my case, DSM-V was replaced with an appeal to authority. when the alternative is "ok boss, you know best" i prefer a list of symptoms where i can argue, "look, almost anyone could tick half these boxes at some point in their lives". at least i can see what's happening. i am not saying that DSM-V is a rule book that should be followed blindly. i am not saying that it is "right", or that it carries some kind of moral weight. all that i am saying is that any communication - even dissent - needs a common vocabulary, and DSM-V can provide that. from my outside perspective it seems that it's a tool; that the real problem is some of the doctors. discarding the tool won't improve the bad doctors, it will just make them less accountable. how is that an improvement?
- harvestmoon 13y agoYou seem to not realize that the DSM-5 can be used to justify treating you with a wide variety of medications. If you feel a little down, occasionally feel a bit energized and happy, and sometimes anxious, using the DSM 5 your shrink can gladly give you: antidepressants antipsychotics anxiety medications and more.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- andrewcooke 13y agodoctors can do what they want anyway. getting rid of DSM-V won't remove those powers. it just removes a way to describe / discuss (and perhaps challenge) what they are doing. so you're actually making things more open to abuse. but i'm not sure if this will help explain things, as i thought my comment above was pretty clear anyway.