3 ms·
I see this come up again and again on HN and this kind of logic keeps getting voted up: "You're complaining about [lesser evil] when there is [bigger unrelated
by sofal 17y ago
I see this come up again and again on HN and this kind of logic keeps getting voted up:
"You're complaining about [lesser evil] when there is [bigger unrelated evil]. Therefore what you say is irrelevant."
Sometimes it takes on this flavor:
"You're worried about the well-being of [one person] when millions are starving every day. Therefore what you say is irrelevant."
Is there some sort of fallacy name for this? This kind of argument says nothing.
- petercooper 17y agoRed Herring: also called a "fallacy of relevance." This occurs when the speaker is trying to distract the audience by arguing some new topic, or just generally going off topic with an argument.