5 ms·
Devil's advocate: Jobs: "Instead of a conventional linear power supply, Holt built one _like_those_used_in_oscilloscopes_." TFA: "It turns out that Apple's po
by Someone 13y ago
Devil's advocate:
Jobs: "Instead of a conventional linear power supply, Holt built one _like_those_used_in_oscilloscopes_."
TFA: "It turns out that Apple's power supply was not revolutionary"
Indeed. If we believe Jobs, it was used in oscilloscopes before.
Jobs probably exaggerated/boasted/lied when he spoke of "ripping off", but this article isn't 100% honest with the facts, either.
- r0h1n 13y agoYou quote selectively from Jobs. Here's the part that's actually his claim: >> "That switching power supply was as revolutionary as the Apple II logic board was," Jobs later said. "Rod doesn't get a lot of credit for this in the history books but he should. Every computer now uses switching power supplies, and they all rip off Rod Holt's design." Jobs wasn't just claiming Holt's power supplies were built like those in oscilloscopes, but that it was practically the ancestor of all modern PC PSUs. The article conclusively dismantles that claim. P.S. The oscilloscope reference seems to be a Red Herring. From the article: >> One puzzling aspect of power supply discussion in the book Steve Jobs[1] is the statement that the Apple II's power supply is "like those used in oscilloscopes", since oscilloscopes are just one small use for switching power supplies. This statement apparently arose because Holt had previously designed a switching power supply for oscilloscopes,[82] but there's no other connection between Apple's power supply and oscilloscope power supplies.
- merraksh 13y agoIt could also be that Steve Jobs had incomplete information. Holt told him he designed such and such (maybe he should have just said implemented), without giving him references for who did it before. Jobs did not bother to find out and the false idea that Holt invented it stuck to his mind. Maybe just an honest mistake, but then due to lack of rigor.
- raverbashing 13y agoI think the "revolutionary" part doesn't mean revolutionary alone, but in the context of computers. There are also several possible structures of switching power supplies, so it may involve a new structure, or a new way of regulating the output, or just saving on components. Revolutionary may be an hyperbole, but it probably had some novelty factor as well. Edit: ok the article explains the patent awarded to the power supply, nothing too fancy. Oh and a TO-3 transistor, brings memories.
- InclinedPlane 13y agoDid you read the article at all? Switching power supplies were common and extremely well-known in industry at the time, and had been used for mini-computers for years. There was nothing truly "revolutionary" about the Apple II's power supply and it's design was not substantially copied by other micro-computer power supplies. None of Jobs' claims are backed by even the slightest shred of evidence.