2 ms·
I think in both cases the best solution is to somehow mandate slack. The temptation is to run both the financial system and the electric grid as hot as possible
by jerf 17y ago
I think in both cases the best solution is to somehow mandate slack. The temptation is to run both the financial system and the electric grid as hot as possible. In the grid case, this means that the grid is running at 100% and if anything goes wrong, the whole thing just unravels as nobody can pick up any slack. In the financial world, this manifests as leveraging as much as possible to grab as much positive investment as possible, and when the investment ticks even the slightest bit negative you get total, massive bankruptcy and unpayable debt.
In both cases, if we didn't leverage so much or run the grid so hot, a failure is much more likely to be contained. The downside is that it is more expensive, you're leaving money on the table or putting up more power capacity than you really "need"... but it only takes one financial disaster to pay for years of slightly less growth, and only one total power failure for an extended period to suck as much value out of the economy as you would have put into building more capacity. If you don't account for the possibility of disaster it looks like a terrible investment, but factor that in and it looks downright prudent.
Look at the stock value graphs of the past 30 years; would you trade a lesser growth rate for not having the past year on your graph? I sure would!
The primary problem as I see it is the question of how you mandate financial slack. Mandating excess power capacity would be relatively straightforward (though it blends with "green energy" initiatives very poorly as they tend to add virtually no baseline power to the grid), but even defining financial "slack" is a challenge, let alone making the system robust. There are just so many games that can be played with paper that it may not be actually possible to prevent huge leverage.
- magoghm 17y agoThe Federal Reserve could have added extra slack very easily just by increasing the reserve requirements. But that goes against what seems to be the Fed's standard inflationary policies.