3 ms·
So you also effectively acknowledge the content of the whole David's answer. The nitpicking point is just the very first sentence, not anything material in the
by acqq 13y ago
So you also effectively acknowledge the content of the whole David's answer. The nitpicking point is just the very first sentence, not anything material in the answer, and only that he wrote "is really made of" instead of "is currently best described as made of." Nitpicking indeed, and irrelevant to anybody reading the whole answer and comparing it with the rest. Because he explicitly shows what and how we are now able to observe, compute and predict. It's the others that present the topic in absolutes.
Once we accept the basic staring point that physics is the loop in which we do the experiments, refine the models, then refine the experiments, etc, we simply don't need to insist on disclaimers that we do it that that way in every our statement.
Most of the other answers come from the previous iterations of the described loop, David's from the more recent.
- yk 13y agoYes, it is a great answer. But someone did make this point, and deleted his comment. And I thought, that this is a interesting detail, which should not be lost for the discussion. Edit:Grammar.
- diminish 13y agosorry for deleting the comment, liked David Z's answer but got downvoted heavily, so i didn't want to bother this thread with philosophical discussions. But now after seeing further discussions half a day later, I think I did wrong. So thanks for great discussions. i was pointing out a problem you may read in feynman's and gerard 't hooft's writings and early quantum physicists, when it comes to interpreting quantum phenomena. What is is? do Mathematical entities have outside existence? Kant, Brentano, Frege, Heidegger, empiricists also touched this issue. ps: I'm a physics graduate and studied/did lab work with CERN neutrino oscillation researchers, so I like such discussions wherever they pop up.