4 ms·
> Or, even simpler: if you have a story with a bad title and a new title you feel strongly about, instead of submitting and then writing a long comment, write a
by saurik 13y ago
> Or, even simpler: if you have a story with a bad title and a new title you feel strongly about, instead of submitting and then writing a long comment, write a blog post about the story and submit that instead.
As stated elsewhere in this thread by others in replies to your suggestion (but sadly much lower on this page, so people will continue to see this earlier comment of yours): short blog posts telling people about another post are generally considered "blogspam" and so thereby posting anything but the original article is not just widely disliked on this site but explicitly violates the guidelines.
"Please submit the original source. If a blog post reports on something they found on another site, submit the latter.".
- cbhl 13y agoWe're already talking about a case where users think that they're smarter than the guidelines, and are choosing to ignore the guideline to use the original title. Between submitting retitled blog spam with commentary and editorializing the title of the original source, I believe the former is a lesser evil. Users can upvote the original source when it is submitted with the original title, while the blog spam falls off of newest. (In the unlikely case that the blog spam has a better title, it will get upvotes as you'd normally expect.) Right now, this editorializing of titles puts a lot of burden on the moderators, and I think that any solution to this issue that we come up with that has to deal with the finite bandwidth of those moderators.
- diminish 13y agohey why not have 2 titles, original and secondary... Moderators would simply identify and delete bad secondary titles and prevent redditization...example: A Farewell --- Android head quits
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- saurik 13y agoSo, I continue to read tptacek's comment to mean "here is something legitimate you can do", not "here's something else you shouldn't do"; if it is the latter, as you are stating, I'm not certain why it was brought up in the first place. Regardless, I take issue with your contention and seemingly fundamental assumption that the article's original title is somehow better and will win out against alternative titles. The entire reason people get angry about this is that the alternative titles are often much more useful: they are more precise, and they are even sometimes less sensationalized. Sometimes titles just need to be different when the material is being viewed in a different context. I've actually been chewed out before for "editorializing the title" when I wrote the original article in a case where my original didn't even have a title because the medium (Google+) doesn't use them. In other cases, the in-context title might need to be very short, but on Hacker News it should be longer. The places you thereby see users actually complaining about this policy are not the places where the submitted title sucked. To demonstrate just how dismissive it is to claim that that is the situation we are discussing: it's like trying to end a debate on whether airport security should strip search anyone who talks about security issues because clearly everyone who does so is a dangerous terrorist. In fact, even people (such as myself) who complain about title changes made on Hacker News often call for title changes, as to many of us the problem is "inaccuracy", not "originality": if the title says something that doesn't seem to be true (as in the case just yesterday regarding the Tesla S's usage of rare earth metals) it isn't the person submitting the link that is "editorializing", it is the original author. Another interesting circumstance was one of the original cases from about a year ago that made this turn into a big public argument: the visualization on the New York Times about some non-hacker aspect of politics. The visualization was insanely impressive, and someone wanted to submit the visualization. The title was clear, factual, and even quite concise: it just labeled the page as being a visualization. In this case, there were tons of interesting comments about the visualization, and people were really excited to see it: the link was clearly a success, it was voted to the front page, and not a single person was bothered that it was there... until some moderator changed the title to the original title of the visualization, which was about some political issue, and now the comments changed in tone. Now, people were arguing about how this wasn't worthy of being on Hacker News: that political issues should be discussed elsewhere; then a fight breaks out about the underlying politics. People are infuriated that somehow this link ended up on the front page with an insane number of votes, and no one has any context due to the policy of changing the titles of posts, even after many hours of discussion in hundreds of comments, without any historical notice that it happened. This is the kind of situation that I think it is reasonable to be bothered by; sure, there are some people who believe that the titles should never be changed under any circumstance, and to the extent to which they exist it is convenient to lump them together with everyone else because "well, people editorialize and there's linkbait so the titles should be changed QED"; but that's not the argument that I've actually seen about title changes: people just want more nuance and more transparency.