3 ms·
Another solution: 1. Allow submitters to submit with whatever title they want, but pull the //title from the page anyway, just to store it. 2. Add an option b
by derefr 13y ago
Another solution:
1. Allow submitters to submit with whatever title they want, but pull the //title from the page anyway, just to store it.
2. Add an option beside the article (maybe visible only on the expanded view of the article-abstract that appears on the comments page) called "flag title". If a few people click this, the title is automatically reverted to the retrieved+stored version.
This way, the people who do "read every article on HN" will be made responsible for deciding what is, or is not, editorializing -- but instead of giving them unlimited power to change the title, they may only reset it to the "true" title. I think that provides the proper balance of incentives.
- eevilspock 13y agoYou're approach works too and I'd think HN would do better by either. My variation considers the case where the original is worse than the imperfect submitted one.