2 ms·
I agree that this policy is sensible from a process standpoint. However, it does end up penalizing the writers who are bad at SEO, or just don't care...and at t
by danso 13y ago
I agree that this policy is sensible from a process standpoint. However, it does end up penalizing the writers who are bad at SEO, or just don't care...and at the same time, it rewards the sites that do cynically partake in link bait titles, all the while being little more than blogspam.
I think my problem is that when a headline is clearly too vague and someone adds a non adjectivey headline, the mods go out of their way to revert it, doing a disservice to everyone. If monitoring titles is a burden, then it seems like it'd be less work in these cases to leave the clarified titles...the community is usually good about flagging it.
Also, do HN mods revert to headline or the title tag? That is, can submitters choose from either (this is significant for most New Yorker articles, which have very short heds by properly descriptive title tags)
- _delirium 13y agoYeah, my main problem with the current policy is that it lowers the overall quality of content by encouraging content from places that are optimizing their titles. Some places even write titles deliberately targeted at HN. Stuff not intended to "go viral" or be marketed, but rather just to provide useful information in a non-HN context, often ends up with completely unintelligible, out-of-context titles, like "Update". But that material is often actually better. I guess I could try to adopt a personal policy of only reading submissions that have vague, out-of-context titles, and see if it works as a kind of reverse heuristic.