3 ms·
> People seem to have this idea that back in the days I don't know who these people are. But many people today see the screens and volumes, and say "see, HFT g
by beagle3 13y ago
> People seem to have this idea that back in the days
I don't know who these people are. But many people today see the screens and volumes, and say "see, HFT gives liquidity!", and that's wrong. I'm not saying HFT took liquidity away (it may have, I don't know, but for sure I didn't claim that). But it does not improve the liquidity that matters to most market participants.
> executing giant orders in one fell swoop hasn't gotten any better under HFT, but it hardly seems to have made it worse.
I agree. I'm just countering the oft repeated meme that "HFT provides liquidity". Essentially, it doesn't.
> I don't know about "often," unless you're talking about trading individual issues where news events introduce a high degree of uncertainty. There's really only been one case of a market-wide drying up of liquidity, which lasted for about 15 minutes during the flash crash.
There's been tens of "flash crash" and "flash smash" events in the last couple of years. Not of the magnitude of the one blamed on Waddell and Reed, but it's still happening.
> There's also nothing new about market-maker liquidity drying up in times of uncertainty or severe volatility.
I agree. I just disagree that HFT are providing any kind of service or benefit to the market. They only benefit themselves, at a cost to the market that goes way beyond the profit from arbitrage/scalping action that they do.
And it is easy to put a stop to: Adopt the rule Eurex and LIFFE had in 2001 that requires 10:1 order:execution ratio.