3 ms·
Thanks for the links. I'll add one link, direct to the project page, since it has links to the actual data, as well as much more detail than is in the articles:
by pdonis 13y ago
Thanks for the links. I'll add one link, direct to the project page, since it has links to the actual data, as well as much more detail than is in the articles:
http://berkeleyearth.org/ http://berkeleyearth.org/
I note two things on a first read-through:
(1) The project confirmed the data on temperature trends, but the error bar sizes are only reasonable back to about 1860; further back than that, the error bars get quite large. This is glossed over in the statements of findings: for example, the summary of findings (http://berkeleyearth.org/summary-of-findings http://berkeleyearth.org/summary-of-findings) says: "Global land temperatures have increased by 1.5 degrees C over the past 250 years", but the error bars in 1750 are about +/- 1.5 C. You can't conclude anything reliably when the error bars are as large as the signal you think you see in the data.
(I also note, btw, that this conclusion is mis-stated in the NYT op-ed by Muller: it says "Our results show that the average temperature of the earth’s land has risen by two and a half degrees Fahrenheit over the past 250 years, including an increase of one and a half degrees over the most recent 50 years". Neither of those statements are consistent with the summary of findings page on the project site, which claims, and shows, 1.5 C rise over the past 250 years, as above, and less than 1 C rise over the past 50 years.)
(2) The project looked at statistics on temperature trends to test whether the "urban heat island" effect might have biased the conclusions; since they saw the same trends when looking at rural areas only, they concluded that it didn't. But that isn't the only criticism Anthony Watts made of the individual station data: he claimed that the locations of many individual thermometers, urban and rural, were poorly chosen (the classic case is one that was placed in the hot air exhaust stream of an air conditioning unit). The Berkeley project did not go and eyeball individual stations, as Watts did, so they had no way of assessing this effect.
- snowwrestler 13y agoa) I'm not the author of the study. b) You expect us to believe that you have developed substantive critiques of a 3-year research project in 24 minutes of reading. (the delta between our post timestamps) c) IMO whatever credibility you might have had to debate the science in detail is forfeited by your un-ironic reliance on the blog of a retired TV weather guy. EDIT: this is wrong, I confused you with another poster in this thread who had previously linked to the Watts blog. My apologies.
- pdonis 13y agoYou expect us to believe that you have developed substantive critiques of a 3-year research project in 24 minutes of reading. I don't expect you to "believe" anything. I expect you to look at the items I pointed out and see what you think of them. If you don't agree with them, feel free to give specific reasons why not. your un-ironic reliance on the blog of a retired TV weather guy. I didn't bring Watts into it; the Berkeley project did. I was merely commenting on something that Watts had emphasized but I didn't see mention of in the first set of links (lamontcg gave another link that does deal with that specific issue, I'll take a look at it).
- snowwrestler 13y agoSorry, that was a snap response. Once again I've taught myself the value of posting slowly. c) is wrong; I mistook you for someone else in the discussion. I noted so in an edit. For the rest, I think lamontcg put it better than I could have.
- pdonis 13y agoc) is wrong; I mistook you for someone else in the discussion. I noted so in an edit. I just saw the edit, thanks for clarifying.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- lamontcg 13y ago"I expect you to look at the items I pointed out and see what you think of them. If you don't agree with them, feel free to give specific reasons why not." You need to do some research first. The fact that you had never heard of the BEST study indicates that you don't know the most superficial details about climate science and this debate (and ones that were splattered across the New York Times). I'm not going to do the work to educate you. I expect YOU to do research before you demand me to produce a 250-paper annotated bibliography of climate science and its justification. Come back when you can explain the radiative physics behind CO2 being a greenhouse gas and how it can be shown in a table-top experiment, and when you know what Milankovich cycles are. Explain what caused the last Ice Age to end, be prepared to discuss the PETM. Explain the theories behind the warming that led up to the Eocene optimum 49 million years ago and the subsequent cooling after that. Climate science is more than just arguing about anthropogenic global warming. If you want a place to start, go here: http://www.amazon.com/Earths-Climate-William-F-Ruddiman/dp/0716737418 http://www.amazon.com/Earths-Climate-William-F-Ruddiman/dp/0... Then start hacking away at these: http://www.amazon.com/Paleoclimatology-International-Geophysics-Raymond-Bradley-ebook/dp/B001UFP65S http://www.amazon.com/Paleoclimatology-International-Geophys... http://www.amazon.com/Principles-of-Planetary-Climate-ebook/dp/B00CF0K3D2 http://www.amazon.com/Principles-of-Planetary-Climate-ebook/... Try getting off the Internet and exposing yourself to some actual science and not arguments about science.
- lamontcg 13y agoThey looked at siting effects as well: http://www.scitechnol.com/2327-4581/2327-4581-1-107.php http://www.scitechnol.com/2327-4581/2327-4581-1-107.php They used Watts own siting data and showed that both poor and good sites showed the same temperature trend over time. The data back to 1860 are also sufficient to establish the current warming trend and through other analysis (e.g. Meehl, et al's work) to establish the climate sensitivity. Climate science as a discipline does not hinge on knowing exactly how warm it was 250 years ago within +/- 0.5C.
- pdonis 13y agoThanks for the link, I'll take a look at it. The data back to 1860 are also sufficient to establish the current warming trend Only if you assume that there are no significant cyclic effects on longer time scales. Climate science as a discipline does not hinge on knowing exactly how warm it was 250 years ago within +/- 0.5C. It does if you're claiming, as the IPCC does based on the input of climate scientists, that temperatures now are warmer than they have been in at least several thousand years.
- XorNot 13y agoThis is not as relevant as you're implying - if there are cyclic effects on long time scales, you're implying they're highly exponential - long periods of no warming, and then sudden periods of rapid warming (oddly correlated with the rise in human CO2 emissions at that). There's no postulated mechanism for how this could be the case - where is the extra energy or heat retention coming from and managing to come into play so suddenly since the 1970s? Whereas, if one accounts for anthropogenic CO2, it explains it superbly.
- pdonis 13y agoif there are cyclic effects on long time scales, you're implying they're highly exponential I'm implying no such thing. Consider an analogy: I look at the temperature trend from February through May and conclude that I have enough data to show a significant warming trend. I therefore predict that by November, the planet will be dangerously overheated. Obviously I have ignored a cyclic effect on a longer timescale. Is it "highly exponential" as you describe? long periods of no warming, and then sudden periods of rapid warming This is not what the data shows; at least, not if you look at all the data, not just a few selected temperature reconstructions that are questionable (at best) anyway. The data in full, looking at a number of different fields, shows a cycle with a period of about 800 to 1000 years; the last iteration of the cycle consisted of the Medieval Warm Period and the Little Ice Age, and we are nearing the next maximum of the cycle now. This is not to say that human activities (of which CO2 emissions are only one component: why is it that nobody talks about land use?) have had no effect on the climate. (Arguably, humans terraforming the planet has been a significant factor in keeping another Ice Age from starting.) But if you're using the wrong baseline, it's tough to separate the human effects from the other effects.