3 ms·
A subpoena? I'm not aware of the protocol, but it may be that Apple could only do this the first time someone sent a message, when keys were established. It mi
by StavrosK 13y ago
A subpoena?
I'm not aware of the protocol, but it may be that Apple could only do this the first time someone sent a message, when keys were established. It might not, I'm just speculating, but it sounds reasonable.
If Apple wanted the protocol to be insecure, they'd have just sent messages in plaintext over TLS and be done with it. The fact that Apple actively designed a reasonably secure, encrypted protocol is evidence that they wanted to protect users against themselves too (to the point where it didn't impact usability).
- otterley 13y agoIf a subpoena were used for this purpose I'd be quite surprised. The Federal Rules of Civil Procedure only allows subpoenas to issue for the following: 1. Compel a witness to testify; 2. Compel someone to produce a document or "tangible thing"; 3. Require someone to allow the inspection of premises. Fed. R. Civ. Proc. Rule 45(a)(1)(A)(iii). I can't imagine the Government would attempt to use subpoena power to force a business to take any other action, and if they tried to do so, as an attorney I would definitely appeal it (and probably prevail). That's not to say there aren't other means at the Government's disposal, but subpoena is definitely not one of them.