5 ms·
the usual HN climate-change critics are in this thread, pointing at and yelling about how science is "broken". I don't think the current situation in climate s
by pdonis 13y ago
the usual HN climate-change critics are in this thread, pointing at and yelling about how science is "broken".
I don't think the current situation in climate science shows that "science is broken". I think it shows that climate scientists have been too quick to claim the credibility of Science when their work does not measure up to that standard. (Climate science is certainly not the only field that does this: much of what passes for "scientific research" in the social sciences doesn't meet the standard either.) That's not to say we shouldn't be trying to figure out how the climate works; it's saying that you don't claim the mantle of Science until you can back it up.
- gilgoomesh 13y ago> climate scientists have been too quick to claim the credibility of Science when their work does not measure up to that standard What the fuck are you talking about? Observations and models are repeated and challenged far more in climate science than most other fields. It is a good example of science working exactly as it should. I'm not sure where you think climate science has gone astray but considering how expensive and difficult controlled experiments in climate science are, I think climate science does an amazingly good job. To clarify: yes, there are lots of bad papers in climate science (see Sturgeon's Law) but science does not require every paper to be accurate (in fact, you need a few extremist ideas to try to shake things up). Science requires rigorous retesting of theories to narrow the target and climate science is one field where that's happening all the time. Climate science's continuous observations does a pretty good job at sidelining inaccurate papers within a couple years (a quick turnaround all things considered). Climate science's problem is non scientists misrepresenting, misinterpreting and misunderstanding. The science itself is exactly what you'd want for every scientific field.
- ISL 13y ago> Observations and models are repeated and challenged far more in climate science than any other field. That may be an overstatement; see the Standard Model of physics.
- gilgoomesh 13y agoYou're right, it was overstatement. I've corrected to "most other fields".
- pdonis 13y agoObservations and models are repeated and challenged far more in climate science than most other fields. You're kidding, right? Please show your work. [Edit: I saw your correction, and have adjusted my quote above, but my response is still the same: please show your work.] science does not require every paper to be accurate (in fact, you need a few extremist ideas to try to shake things up). I quite agree, and I wasn't trying to claim that all, or even most, papers published in other fields are accurate. Climate science's problem is non scientists misrepresenting, misinterpreting and misunderstanding. The science itself is exactly what you'd want for every scientific field. I disagree, but I doubt we're going to resolve the question here.
- lamontcg 13y ago+1 on "what the fuck are you talking about?" Climate science even got a physics prof from Berzerkely (who was convinced that only physicists knew how to do science right) who went in with an anti-climatology bias, and was funded by the Koch brother, and he replicated climatology results in the "BEST" study -- to the point where journals like Nature turned down publishing the BEST study because it was not new information and only confirming already well known scientific facts. So a Koch-backed study has actually determined that climate science really is science. That's like the Catholic church in the 1600s funding someone to investigate Galileo and publishing that it looks like the Earth goes around the Sun after all...
- pdonis 13y agoa Koch-backed study has actually determined that climate science really is science Reference, please?
- snowwrestler 13y agohttp://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/wonkblog/post/a-skeptical-physicist-ends-up-confirming-climate-data/2011/10/20/gIQA6viC1L_blog.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/wonkblog/post/a-skeptica... http://www.nytimes.com/2012/07/30/opinion/the-conversion-of-a-climate-change-skeptic.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2012/07/30/opinion/the-conversion-of-...
- pdonis 13y agoThanks for the links. I'll add one link, direct to the project page, since it has links to the actual data, as well as much more detail than is in the articles: http://berkeleyearth.org/ http://berkeleyearth.org/ I note two things on a first read-through: (1) The project confirmed the data on temperature trends, but the error bar sizes are only reasonable back to about 1860; further back than that, the error bars get quite large. This is glossed over in the statements of findings: for example, the summary of findings (http://berkeleyearth.org/summary-of-findings http://berkeleyearth.org/summary-of-findings) says: "Global land temperatures have increased by 1.5 degrees C over the past 250 years", but the error bars in 1750 are about +/- 1.5 C. You can't conclude anything reliably when the error bars are as large as the signal you think you see in the data. (I also note, btw, that this conclusion is mis-stated in the NYT op-ed by Muller: it says "Our results show that the average temperature of the earth’s land has risen by two and a half degrees Fahrenheit over the past 250 years, including an increase of one and a half degrees over the most recent 50 years". Neither of those statements are consistent with the summary of findings page on the project site, which claims, and shows, 1.5 C rise over the past 250 years, as above, and less than 1 C rise over the past 50 years.) (2) The project looked at statistics on temperature trends to test whether the "urban heat island" effect might have biased the conclusions; since they saw the same trends when looking at rural areas only, they concluded that it didn't. But that isn't the only criticism Anthony Watts made of the individual station data: he claimed that the locations of many individual thermometers, urban and rural, were poorly chosen (the classic case is one that was placed in the hot air exhaust stream of an air conditioning unit). The Berkeley project did not go and eyeball individual stations, as Watts did, so they had no way of assessing this effect.
- vacri 13y agoDid you bother reading the article? Because it specifically says that not only are the usual soft targets like psychology a problem, but so are hard STEM targets like cancer research. Also, what's with the capitalising of Science like it's some kind of club or organisation? "Science" is not a proper noun - making it one is facilitating dogma.
- pdonis 13y agoso are hard STEM targets like cancer research. Yes, that's true; I shouldn't have singled out social sciences. what's with the capitalising of Science like it's some kind of club or organisation? It's meant to convey the fact that climate scientists basically tell politicians "look, Science says you have to do X, Y, Z or we're doomed". They are claiming that their results are good enough to drive policy choices that have huge consequences, and politicians believe it because it's Science--they see it as the same as if astronomers came to them and said "look, we've calculated that asteroid A is going to hit the Earth unless we do X, Y, and Z; we've checked the numbers every which way and there's no other option." But climate science as a field is simply not accurate enough to justify that.
- kzrdude 13y agoThere is a book about the "bubble" of string theory research written by a physicist, but the title and author slip my mind right now. It discusses the very phenomenon that research grants go to increasingly bigger groups that can be trusted to deliver. And also string theory research itself which did get a ton of grant money during the 1990's even though the results never had impact outside the bubble itself. Edit, some searching helped me find it: Lee Smolin, The Trouble with Physics http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Trouble_with_Physics http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Trouble_with_Physics