3 ms·
>For example, a subject may report a silly thought as a creative one instead of as a stupid one. You would have to assume that I was subconsciously also lying
by gwern 13y ago
>For example, a subject may report a silly thought as a creative one instead of as a stupid one.
You would have to assume that I was subconsciously also lying in the predictions, to hide my foreknowledge, and how would I be able to precisely affect the sleep or Mnemosyne scores?
> Also, given that the period of the experiment is exactly a week, I also would control for 'LSD is the first thing exactly as often as the test"
? 3-day blocks imply a 6-day cycle, not 'exactly a week'. And I'm not sure what you mean by 'control' either.
- Someone 13y agoI must have interpreted the "finally" in "on day 7, examine the containers recording whether active/placebo and finally, starting over as day 1 of a new pair of 3-day blocks." And control: see http://thesocietypages.org/socimages/2013/01/12/what-does-it-mean-to-control-for-something/ http://thesocietypages.org/socimages/2013/01/12/what-does-it...
- gwern 13y ago> And control: see http://thesocietypages.org/socimages/2013/01/12/what-does-it.. http://thesocietypages.org/socimages/2013/01/12/what-does-it.... Yes, I'm aware of the statistical concept, and do controlling in a few other essays. My point was: 'control' is not an instantly obvious application. What am I controlling and how? Am I modeling it as a separate additive categorical variable? Quantitative variable? An interaction? (All different in R's formula notation, because they're different - +, *, :, and |) When you say > I also would control for 'LSD is the first thing exactly as often as the test" I don't even know what I would be controlling here, since I don't know what the order is supposed, what the 'test' is, and so on. You may think your suggestion is clear, but to me it's as clear as mud.
- Someone 13y agoIf your cycle is 7 days (which it isn't, but which I initially understood it to be), you will want to make sure that, with an experiment running for 2N weeks, you take the LSD-spiked water exactly N times on Monday and N times on Thursday, rather than relying on luck to get close to that. One way to do that is to make 2N packages containing a spiked and a non-spiked sample, with one sample marked 'take me first', and, in N cases, have the LSD-spiked sample be that sample. Of course, if you do that, it is even more important to not inform the subject about the history of he experiment before it is over.
- gwern 13y ago> If your cycle is 7 days (which it isn't, but which I initially understood it to be), you will want to make sure that, with an experiment running for 2N weeks, you take the LSD-spiked water exactly N times on Monday and N times on Thursday, rather than relying on luck to get close to that. I see. So you were suggesting throwing in a categorical variable for the day of week and including that as a additive covariate to control for fixed-effects on days. I haven't actually run into any of my experiments depending on day of week to any important degree, but I still try to avoid 7-day blocks to make that less of an issue. It's not like there's usually an advantage to running in a weekly block, so better safe than sorry.