3 ms·
Is this anything other than the species problem [0]? Based on this quote: > "If you found the Dmanisi skulls at isolated sites in Africa, some people would giv
by baddox 13y ago
Is this anything other than the species problem [0]? Based on this quote:
> "If you found the Dmanisi skulls at isolated sites in Africa, some people would give them different species names. But one population can have all this variation. We are using five or six names, but they could all be from one lineage."
it sounds like it's just a semantic question of how exactly the "species" are divided up logically.
[0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Species_problem http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Species_problem
- lisper 13y agoNot quite. If skulls are segregated by morphology AND time and/or distance that is evidence that there are two distinct species, i.e. if the big skulls are always over here and the little ones are always over there (or the big ones are always in this layer and the little ones always in that). But if you find different morphologies together in the same time and place that is evidence that they were all members of the same species because it is rare to have two different species occupying the same ecological niche.
- netcan 13y agoWell, inevitably its partly that. But it seems there are is a real finding here even if we avoid the word species entirely. Basically it's evidence of morphological diversity within even a very narrow definition of the word species. If you know that bulldogs and Yorkshire terriers are the same species it's a lot easier to argue that your fossil of a great Dane is too, even though it looks very different. That means you don't need millions of years to evolve it. If the diversity is there in the species, selective pressures can make a different looking variety/subspecies quickly. Modern humans are not that diverse in size. An adult males weigh 50-85kgs. If you find a population of individuals weiging 120ks, you will conclude that these are probably a different species.
- tjr 13y agoModern humans are not that diverse in size. An adult males weigh 50-85kgs. If you find a population of individuals weiging 120ks, you will conclude that these are probably a different species. Haven't been in the U.S. much, have you? :-(
- 001sky 13y agoAt least one in two people are now overweight or obese in more than half of the 34 OECD countries
- dragonwriter 13y ago> Modern humans are not that diverse in size. An adult males weigh 50-85kgs. Or a little less, or a lot more. > If you find a population of individuals weiging 120ks, you will conclude that these are probably a different species. Assumign "ks" is supposed to be "kg", it might just be a gathering of NFL players. [1] [1] http://www.espn.go.com/espn/page2/story?page=merron/041124_rankings http://www.espn.go.com/espn/page2/story?page=merron/041124_r...