3 ms·
I respectfully disagree. Maximal competitiveness means making elections closer, outcomes more uncertain. Every election race should be a knife fight. (A side e
by specialist 13y ago
I respectfully disagree.
Maximal competitiveness means making elections closer, outcomes more uncertain. Every election race should be a knife fight. (A side effect of this will be to boost voter turnout, increasing the legitimacy of the elections.)
My views are informed/inspired by the lessons learned BC's Citizens Assembly on Election Reform's efforts.
"The Case for Redistricting Juries: Lessons from British Columbia’s Revolutionary Experiment in Democratic Reform"
http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1405605 http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1405605
I've been following your other comments re FPTP vs proportional. Good stuff. While I support proportional representation for assemblies (eg council, House), it conflicts with my support for direct democracy, which I haven't fully reconciled yet. I'm sure you understand.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> Maximal competitiveness means making elections closer, outcomes more uncertain. Yes, it does. That also means, in FPTP, maximizing dissatisfaction with the outcome. > Every election race should be a knife fight. I disagree. Every election should produce effective representation of the electors; FPTP elections -- metaphorical "knife fights" or otherwise -- do not do that, and engineering them for maximal competitiveness invokes one failure mode (maximal general election dissatisfaction) in order to minimize another (the failure mode wherein the general election is non-competitive, so the real choice is made in the process which selects candidates for the general election.) > While I support proportional representation for assemblies (eg council, House), it conflicts with my support for direct democracy, which I haven't fully reconciled yet. Direct democracy is proportional representation taken to one extreme. I don't see why supporting PR for what representative offices exists should conflict with a preference for direct democracy.
- specialist 13y agoThat also means, in FPTP, maximizing dissatisfaction with the outcome. Ah. Now I get your meaning. I don't see why supporting PR for what representative offices exists should conflict with a preference for direct democracy. Having done some lobbying in the USA, I wonder how effective lobbying would be where PR is used.